Wow...Anthony's on a roll :-) His superhero looked great even without the chest and back pieces. (He couldn't get the molds done in time, so he went with Plan B.)
I think he won over the other guy because he did what Jim Lee and the other guy at the beginning said...superheros almost always use the primary colors, and the other superhero was kinda pink and gray. (OK, not really, but that's what it looked like unless you were really close.)
I wasn't surprised at who went home...if you're on a show like Face Off, you really need to do some makeup. Or appliances. Not just a mask and costume.
(Note: I'm still a bit weak on all the names.)