Well while we're talking men who aren't considered traditionally good-looking (if at all), and who are as far from being "pretty boys" as they can get, I am a longstanding Tommy Lee Jones fan. Been loving him since the 1990's when I devoured every single movie I could find with him in it because I couldn't get enough of him. Ask me how many times I've watched movies like The Client and The Fugitive and US Marshals, all for a tasty glimpse of Mr. Jones?? I'm pretty sure I've seen every movie he's ever been in. And the thing others deem to render him unattractive, i.e., his craggy, rugged face, is the thing I love the most about him. He's aging now, yes, but this talented man still does it for me.