I like a man who is not only able to do things....a Mr. Fix-It, if you will, but is smart! A nice physique is also delightful. Smart is sexy!! Johnny Depp is too tiny, but he is good at his craft, and THAT is sexy. My former husband was a fix-it guy with a decent body.
Brad Pitt seems like he's just a good man, in general, and he's a good actor, but I like him cleaned up.