Mia Farrow And Second Witness Say Naomi Campbell Lied About 'Blood Diamonds'
Mia Farrow and Carole White, Supermodel's Former Agent, Say Campbell Knew Diamonds Were Coming
By ANNA SCHECTER
Aug. 9, 2010 —
Naomi Campbell's former modeling agent testified today that she believes the supermodel knew the alleged 'blood diamonds' she received from two men in the middle of the night were actually from dictator Charles Taylor, and that Campbell had been flirting with the warlord during dinner and was expecting the gift.
Carole White, Campbell's ex-agent, became the second witness to take the stand at an international war crimes trial Monday and dispute important elements of Campbell's testimony to the same body last Thursday. Former Liberian president Charles Taylor is on trial in the Hague for allegedly using uncut "blood diamonds' to fuel a bloody civil war, and prosecutors say Taylor's alleged gift of the gems to Campbell after a 1997 dinner at Nelson Mandela's house is proof the now-deposed dictator was buying guns in South Africa.
Earlier Monday, actress Mia Farrow disputed the supermodel's claim under oath that she did not know where the gift of "blood diamonds" had come from. White added detail to Farrow's story, saying that Campbell had been seated next to Taylor at the dinner, had flirted with him, was in communication with his representatives, and was expecting the gift of diamonds when it arrived.
"Naomi was very excited and said, 'Oh, he's going to give me some diamonds,' " claimed White. She said Taylor and Campbell were being "charming" to each other at the dinner. "Naomi I think was flirting with him and he was flirting back."
The penalty for lying to the Special Court for Sierra Leone, where Taylor is being tried for 11 different war crime counts, is a fine and up to two years in jail. A court spokesman had no comment when asked by ABC News whether any charges would be brought against Campbell should the court conclude that she had lied.
White also claimed that after the dinner, Campbell was in contact with representatives of Taylor, and that she knew they had gone from Pretoria to Johannesburg to collect some diamonds. White said that after the men came to Campbell's room, she and Campbell welcomed the men and gave them cokes. The men then gave Campbell "a scruffy piece of paper," according to White, that contained the diamonds.
Campbell was "quite disappointed because they weren't shining," said White.
White, who is currently involved in a legal dispute with Campbell, also said it was her idea, and not Campbell's, to give the diamonds to charity. Campbell testified Thursday that she had given the diamonds to Jeremy Ractliffe, the then-director of the Nelson Mandela Children's Fund, and Ractliffe later confirmed that he had received some uncut stones from Campbell. Ractliffe gave the diamonds to South African special police on Thursday.
Both White and Farrow were present at the dinner in September 1997 at which Campbell and Taylor met. Before White took the stand, Farrow testified that Campbell knew exactly who sent her diamonds after the dinner. Defense lawyers responded by playing an ABC News report on the alleged "blood diamond" gift that aired on Nightline, and tried to suggest that it showed Farrow was biased.
Farrow told the court what happened at breakfast the next morning: "[Campbell] was quite excited and she said last night I was awakened by someone knocking at the door. They were men sent from Charles Taylor and they gave me a huge diamond!"
Campbell testified Aug. 5th that at breakfast, Farrow told her the gift must have been from Taylor because no one else at the dinner could have given her uncut diamonds.
"Did you tell Naomi Campbell that the diamond or diamonds came from Charles Taylor?" Prosecutor Nick Koumjian asked Farrow on the stand today.
"Absolutely not. Naomi said they came from Charles Taylor," Farrow replied.
Taylor's defense attorneys tried to poke holes in Farrow's testimony, asking leading questions about the clarity of her recollection, noting that several people including Campbell have said there were several diamonds, not one "huge diamond" as Farrow recalls Campbell saying.
The defense asked Farrow about a quote from the Nightline segment, in which Farrow can be heard saying, "I am eager to see the people of Liberia and Sierra Leone see justice. They need that." Farrow denied that it showed she was biased.
Campbell told the court last week that two men she came to believe to be representative of the warlord had given her a pouch containing several "dirty-looking" diamonds, and that she had give the gems to Jeremy Ractliffe, then director of the Nelson Mandel Children's Fund, so he could sell them and use the money for the charity. Campbell had previously denied to ABC News that she received any gems from Taylor.
Ractliffe confirmed that he received three uncut diamonds from Campbell in 1997. South African police say Ractliffe brought them the gems August 5th.
In a statement released Aug. 9th, Ractliffe said that he had received "three small uncut diamonds" on Sept. 26, 1997. "I took them because I thought it might well be illegal for her to take uncut diamonds out of the country," explained Ractliffe. "Naomi suggested they could be of some benefit to the Nelson Mandela Children's Fund, but I told her I would not involve the NMCF in anything that could possibly be illegal."
"In the end I decided I should just keep them," said Ractliffe, who felt that it was in the best interest of NMCF, former South African president Mandela, and Campbell, "none of who were benefitting in any way."
Ractliffe told ABC News he gave the diamonds to South Africa's special police, known as the Hawks, on Thursday. On Friday, a spokesman for the Hawks told South African media they had received the diamonds and were having them authenticated.
Taylor has denied giving diamonds to Campbell. In a statement to ABC News, Taylor's defense attorneys continued to dispute the story. Said attorney Terry Munyard, "If the court finds that these things were diamonds and they were the gift of Mr. Taylor and therefore says he also bought arms and ammunition for Sierra Leonean rebels on that trip to South Africa, the defense says no competent criminal court could possibly make such a huge leap from one small fact to another."
Prior to her testimony Thursday, Campbell had told ABC News that she never received a diamond from Taylor. She reluctantly appeared at the Special Court for Sierra Leone in The Hague to give her version of events the night she met Taylor at the home of Nelson Mandela in 1997. She arrived at court under police protection, and said during testimony that appearing was an "inconvenience" for her.
On the stand, Campbell claimed two men came to her room at Nelson Mandela's residence in the middle of the night after a dinner at which she'd met Charles Taylor for the first time. She says the men woke her up, said "A gift for you," and handed her a pouch with several "dirty-looking" stones inside with no note or explanation.
She denied that she had been flirtatious with Taylor at dinner or had been seated next to him, or that he had told her he planned to give her a gift of diamonds. She said she had not been in contact with him since the dinner.
She said she had given the stones to Ractliffe in hopes they could be used for charity.
"I just said take them, do something with them, make sure some children benefit from them," she told chief prosecutor Brenda Hollis.
Campbell said that Ractliffe told her he did not have time to sell the stones, and that he still has them.
Campbell was subpoenaed by the international tribunal following an ABC News report about allegations that Taylor had given her the uncut "blood diamonds."
Until the ABC News report, Campbell had refused to cooperate with the court. Taylor is charged with 11 counts of war crimes and crimes against humanity.
Campbell testified Thursday that she had never heard of Taylor, Liberia or blood diamonds when she met the Liberian president in 1997.
The prosecution first learned of the alleged gift of "blood diamonds" from Farrow. After an ABC News report on the alleged gift, Carole White came forward and told prosecutors that she was also at the dinner, and was with Campbell later that evening when a group of Taylor's men delivered a half-dozen uncut diamonds.
Campbell was "disappointed" by the stones, according to White's lawyer Daniel Bright, because they were not yet cut to sparkle like the diamonds used in jewelry.
Farrow told ABC News that she saw Campbell the morning after the dinner. According to Farrow, Campbell was "all a-twitter" when she recounted how she was given "a huge diamond" by Taylor's men in the middle of the night.
In court Thursday, Campbell denied discussing the size of the diamonds after receiving them. She said she had breakfast with White and Mia Farrow the morning after receiving the pouch, and that one of the two women suggested to her then that the gift must have come from Taylor because no one else at the dinner would've given her such a gift.
Campbell Denies Receiving Diamonds
When ABC News asked Campbell about the incident at New York Fashion Week in February, she denied ever having received a blood diamond.
"I didn't receive a diamond and I'm not going to speak about that, thank you very much. And I'm not here for that," said Campbell.
She stormed out of the interview, slapping a producer's camera.
Less than two weeks after ABC News aired the report about the alleged blood diamond gift, Campbell appeared on Oprah saying that she "did not want to be involved in this man's case," but she did not confirm or deny receiving a diamond. "He has done some terrible things and I don't want to put my family in danger," Campbell told Oprah and her millions of viewers in early May.
Campbell's lawyer, Gideon Benaim, said that she is only a witness at Taylor's trial, and it is not alleged that she has done anything wrong.
"Naomi has not done anything wrong. She is a witness and not on trial herself," said Benaim.
Taylor has been on trial for almost three years at the U.N.'s Special Court for Sierra Leone, which is being held at the World Court in the Netherlands, and has pleaded not guilty to all charges against him.
The warfare in Sierra Leone, where diamonds were used by African rebels and allegedly by Taylor to raise money for a bloody rampage from 1997 to 2001, killed or maimed tens of thousands. Taylor's lawyers have argued there is scant direct evidence that connects Taylor to the diamonds or the atrocities.
"The issue here is not whether such atrocities were indeed committed but who was responsible and specifically was Charles Taylor the person responsible," Courtenay Griffiths, Taylor's lead counsel, told ABC News.
Taylor has angrily denied dealing in blood diamonds. When pressed on the stand in November by Brenda Hollis about whether he sent his men to give a diamond to Campbell, Taylor called the allegation "total nonsense."