7/03 Show Discussion Thread *SPOILERS*

[IdolCanadien]

So Scotty who do you think will be leaving Wednesday night. My picks to get rid of based on tonight would be Greg & Brandon.

[scotty2004]

The guys that I think are in trouble are...
Greg...the guy who did Rocket Man...probably in big trouble
Chad..sang Save the Last Dance
Rob...Sang Heaven...could be in only a little trouble..perhaps just a wake-up call

Brandon...singing Queen....I agree that it was forced

[IdolCanadien]

Yeah Chad & Rob should be in the bottom 4 along with Greg & Brandon. See you tomorrow night when the girls take to the stage.

[scotty2004]

So Scotty who do you think will be leaving Wednesday night. My picks to get rid of based on tonight would be Greg & Brandon.

I'm not sure...I agree that those two could go but Chad was right in there with them.

[scotty2004]

Thanks for the company Idol Canadein and looking forward to seeing some improvement tomorrow. (from last week, that is)

[SamsMom]

Hi--coming in a bit late... just a couple of comments:
I agree that the guys were not as fantastic this week as they were last week!!! Last week I just loved them. This week, not so much. For example, last week I really liked Chad but this week thought he was horrible ...

My favourites by a mile are Sheldon and Keith. I hope Sheldon makes it through another week. It seems he barely squeaked by last week. I'm really fond of his voice and personality. Craig and Rob sing well in my opinion but I'm not crazy about either of them.

I felt sorry for Brandon--I think the judges were pretty mean to him. He seems like a sweet kid, but it was pretty bad tonight, that performance.

I sure hope Sheldon sticks around.

[guide54]

For those who haven't seen the show, these were the songs
1-866-943650
1. Greg Neufeld - Rocket Man
2. Tyler Lewis - Mamma I'm Coming HOme
3. Chris Labelle - we shall be free
4. Craig Sharpe - This I promise you
5. Sheldon Elter - Moondance
6. Chad Doucette - Save the last dance for me
7. Rob James - Heaven
8. Brandon Jones - Somebody to Love
9. keith Macpherson - Best I ever had

This wasn't as good as last week and I think song choice had alot to do with it. My favourites this week aren't the same ones as last week either.

Keith still did the best job, but I didn't enjoy Craig as much as last week or Chris Labelle as much. I thought Rob James improved alot, also liked Tyler.

Random jottings on the judges thought's on Keith -
Jake - perfect
Sass - can I have your autograph (and banter back - can I have yours - on my sweater?)
Farley - immaculate tone - you know exactly what to sing
Zack -a travesty if you don't make top 10 now could one of you rock next week

[Salty Sea Hag]

I'm dialing but getting a message saying that the number isn't available in my area at this time.

[Salty Sea Hag]

ok, i figured out the problem...doh