Hey have you noticed this...
I was watching the show with a straight friend and he noticed something that I hadn't. When it comes to the elimination round he noticed that the guys were hugging James differently. Based on that, he correctly guessed that Dan and Michael were straight and Matthew was gay.
Dan, Michael, Wes, and Shawn hugged James with their chins on his shoulder looking straight back (with a little pat on his back). On the other hand, the others nuzzled their noses into his neck. Based on this little observation, Wes and Shawn are the straight guys that are left and all the others are gay.
I don't now if this topic has shown up here yet, but I thought it was interesting observation. If anyone has any of the old eposides to watch again, see if this holds true for all the other eliminated men.