Now that Arthur is gone, everyone can go back to worrying about their own stay at the ranch. Yes, I get it; Arthur does still really need to be there more than some of the others. He is an adult - he has been taught what to do. The Arthur show is over and now it's up to each contestant to make sure the most imporant person stays - herself or himself! I do love Bob and Jillian and am going to miss Jillian (is Bob staying?) next season.
I am just not feeling Brett and Cara. The boxaholics really need to show their teams doing other things besides boxing, shaking ropes and sliding weights. I am really still rooting for the black team but I really can only see Courtney losing quite a bit more to even eke out a win - the women are doing great! It looks like B&C will have the winner (blah) this time. There's nobody that I am really pulling for on that team except maybe Kaylee (almost done) and Austin - because they are both so young.
Since they go by percentage the black team has a strong chance of survival but not next week. Clearly the red team will show higher percentages because of their poor showing this week.
Arthur. I am glad to see him gone so I don't have to watch people sacrificing themselves to save him. He doesn't need to be there more than anyone else. He needs to aquire whatever it takes to do this, no matter where he is. He was being cottled by his team and pushed along. This is not going to help in in the long run and as we have heard, by a spotting, he does not appear to have lost much more.
I agree. This was a clear indication that his thought process was not in the right place.Quote:
rozzi17 wrote: I think the second stupidest was that he swapped a strong team for a weaker one. The goal is to make your team stronger to lessen the chance to lose a weigh-in. If he had swapped to have one of the stronger couples come over to black (like Rulon & Matt) that would have made more sense to me.
I will enjoy this show much more now. I prefer it when the contestants are more even in weight distribution and no one is this heavy. This seems to be a new trend. If they are paying attentioin to feedback they may stop this. However, they look at ratings and we all still watch. :shrug And I will continue but it just isn't as enjoyable.
His reasoning for taking Sarah and Deni was that they would be the sacrificial lambs if/when his team lost a weigh-in. If he had chose Rulon & Justin, and they had lost a weigh-in, his team might have considered keeping Rulon and Justin as they are strong players, thereby putting him/his father at risk of elimination. It wasn't necessarily the nicest thought-process, in terms of Sarah and Deni, but it was understandable, and I don't blame him for it. Though I do blame him for announcing what he had done - that was stupid. I liked/like Arthur. I'm not sad that the Red team eliminated him - everyone has to look out for themselves and everyone has the right to vote out who they want. And I think that Bob & Jillian are hypocritical because if they were that concerned about Arthur staying on the ranch, they could have had the producers keep him on the ranch as a non-competing player. I'm sure the producers would have acquiesced to Bob & Jillian's request - they have power.
Well I miss him and I respect the guy. Totally agreeing with B and J. The red team is selfish. Arthur lost 16 pounds so he did very well for his team but because of that stupid alliance and the 2 bosses he had to go.
I love to see him in the finale and win the home price. I totally do not like the red team and that was even before they sent Arthur away.
Arthur lost 16 pounds because his team got on his case. He was not motivated when he arrived. And this should be rewarded?
This illustrates exaclty why no one of this extreme weight should be on a show with others so much lighter. The weights must be closer so no one stands out as "needing it more."
I say, everyone for themselves. :yay
That indeed might be the answer--keep the initial weights of the contestants closer together so no one becomes the person who most needs to be there.
It also aggravates me that Courtney, who was also very big for her age and gender, but far more motivated, doesn't get nearly the same attention. I guess she doesn't "need" to be there, because she is willing to do the work on her own, which she demonstrated by losing a good deal of weight before even arriving at the ranch.
I don't like the whole notion of people feeling they have to sacrifice themselves for other contestants. I don't like it when contestants seem to be deliberately playing the game, so to speak, to advance themselves at the cost of others (water loading one week for a big loss the next, for instance or leading others to think there's an alliance they don't intend to honor) but I don't think they should feel they have to keep someone around because he/she "needs" to be there either. They all need to be there or they wouldn't be there in the first place.
Tilden, I agree except the water loading. The longer they stay, the faster they lose. I see water loading as a brilliant move! It illustrates motivation to stay. This is also a game show; there is a lot of money involved.
Many of the challenges are set up to encourage the game play aspect. Just because B and J get all freaky at waterloading and take it as a personal afront does not mean this is not a good tactic. The trainers should not shame those who play the game. Their job is to steer their workouts and food intake. The game part has nothing to do with them and they should stay out of it.