Who might be the top picks for All Stars 2?

[MFWalkoff]

Here's who I would want: (Thanks to TheIrishEyes for making the Houseguest Quick Reference Thread in the show forum)

BB8
Eric - definitely
Nick
Jen
maybe Jessica

BB9
Jacob
Sheila

BB10
Dan (although he would be target #1)
Renny
Keesha
Libra
Michelle

BB11
Kevin
Laura
Casey

BB12
Matt
Britney
Ragan
Lane

BB13
Dominic!
Cassi
...maybe Lawon for comic relief

[Gutmutter]

I'm confused as to why Dominic or Cassi would be considered an all-star.

[munkeechi]

Assuming it would start with BB 8:

BB 8:

Dick
Eric
Dustin

BB 9
Amanda
Joshuah
James
Sheila

BB 10
Renny
Jerry
Dan

BB 11
Casey
Lydia
Kevin

BB 12
Matt
Ragen
Brit

BB 13
None of them. Maybe Lawon..

Some just for the controversy they'd cause and the drama.. some because I just really liked them in their season

[munkeechi]

Since the feeds will be down for a while and there was a little speculation yesterday about All Stars 2 candidates, I thought it might be a good time to throw out top picks for an All Stars 2 cast.

I have no idea what the parameters would be for such a cast--would the list begin with Season 8 (post-All Stars), or would people from all seasons be eligible?

Here is what we know so far (all, of course, subject to change on a dime):
--Jeff told Julie Chen in his exit interview that he wasn't interested in going back in the house
--Jordan confirmed Jeff's sentiment in a discussion with Rachel and Adam (I think it was Adam) a day or so after Jeff's eviction; no, they would not be back in the house
--Rachel, in the same conversation, said Brendan also determined that he and she would not be on any more reality tv shows
--Dick doesn't want to be in the house if Dani is there, too (thanks again, Mari!)
--Dan's current employment status is Football Coach, which means his job begins in the summer, so he would not likely be a houseguest due to the conflict

With that said, who do you think the frontrunners are for the next All Stars?

Also don't forget you can't pick Adam or Matt from Season 9 because they're both in jail

[Mari79]

I think if anyone "deserves" a second chance at BB ....it would be "Stein" (Eric, Season 8)

I can't believe i didn't write Stein, yes he definitely deserves a shot, now i guess it's whether he wants a proper shot or not. I thought the America's Player thing really cost him a lot Season 8.

[Allie]

I can't believe i didn't write Stein, yes he definitely deserves a shot, now i guess it's whether he wants a proper shot or not. I thought the America's Player thing really cost him a lot Season 8.

I agree with Eric season 8, definitely. Give him a chance to play without the AP.

[JustJuls]

I can't believe i didn't write Stein, yes he definitely deserves a shot, now i guess it's whether he wants a proper shot or not. I thought the America's Player thing really cost him a lot Season 8.

It did. But he also chose not to use it to his advantages. The majority of America wanted to keep Dick and Dani safe....he was the ONLY person who was priveleged enough to know that....why not work WITH them, no matter what they are like. He would have gotten a lot further had he not went against "us."

But yeah, I would LOVE to see him play without AP.

[MFWalkoff]

I'm confused as to why Dominic or Cassi would be considered an all-star.

It's my opinion. I liked them more than most of the people who lasted. Plus the selection is limited for BB13, since none of the Vets should be eligible, again in my opinion.

[mountaingirl70]

Also don't forget you can't pick Adam or Matt from Season 9 because they're both in jail

holy smokes! really? what did they do?

[MFWalkoff]

holy smokes! really? what did they do?

'Big Brother' Star Pleads Guilty to Drug Ring Charge | TMZ.com

Adam was sentenced to four years. Matt is in jail but I don't know what his sentence was. Matt is still facing charges for allegedly beating his girlfriend and then intimidating her from pressing charges.