Can you ladies explain to me why she picked Ed? Dude left her. She wasn't hugely upset over it. Then she picks him in the end. Isn't that kind of weird? But then he was the only one who right out said he would propose to her at the end. Kip and Reid wouldn't commit to that. So was that the magic bullet? Would Jillian have picked Kip if he flat out said he would propose to her at the end?