Bachelorette 5**** Spoilers, episode 9 with screencaps

[GuardianAngel]

[quote=anders332;3541224;]

Originally Posted by northernviewer

i'm going to if the brown suit is actually brown and the blue suit is actually blue.

Me too! and the blue tile is actually blue. At this point, that's all I care about right now!!! That whole photoshopping blue suit turns into brown suit almost made me go off the deep end. I was soooo confused !!!

[Google]

 

[sclilred1]

Originally Posted by pattycake92

The suit may have been altered but they can't alter the height of the guy. That is def. NOT Ed. I think it is Kip but it wouldn't surprise me if it is Reid either. Whoever it is, they are f2 not f1 JMO

If you would recheck my post I said nothing about them altering the guys height. I simply stated that the guy Jillian is hugging may not be in a brown suit as the SC looks to be altered. I have also not said who I think that the guy is. As far as if it is F1 or F2 guy, TPTB have in seasons past shown us the F1 guy in an "uncomfortable" looking SC with the lead. They have also shown us a "happy, loving" SC of the F2 with the lead. TPTB will and have done this to throw people off. I firmly believe that the suit color is NOT what they are showing us in the SC that I posted. Is it grey? Could be, I have no idea. Is it brown? Could be, I have no idea. However, I honestly do not think that the suit is the exact shade of brown in that particular SC.

[tenngal]

[quote=GuardianAngel;3542034;]

Originally Posted by anders332

Me too! and the blue tile is actually blue. At this point, that's all I care about right now!!! That whole photoshopping blue suit turns into brown suit almost made me go off the deep end. I was soooo confused !!!

I had my brother look at it and he thinks the blue is blue and the brown is brown. He is a photographer and he didn't see that it was changed so until someone proves differently I am going with that.

[stickle]

Originally Posted by GuardianAngel

I had my brother look at it and he thinks the blue is blue and the brown is brown. He is a photographer and he didn't see that it was changed so until someone proves differently I am going with that.

There was a very good analysis on Jokers about the color. The tiles behind the walker are obviously blue and they turn to more of a brownish color under the man's feet. If he's walking under a canopy, the canopy would block the sun and change the lighting on the tiles. The sun is obviously going down from the way it shines on the railing and you can see the rays reaching under the canopy a little bit before the shading comes into effect.

There are numerous screen caps of the man walking and as each one captures him walking further under the canopy, the colors of him and his suit will change too.

[northernviewer]

I've always thought that brown suit hugging guy is bending over to hug her, it's always reminded me of the sc of Ed and Jillian hugging in the fountain. Also, when I look at the hairline of the guy, I think the one guy that I can rule out is Kiptyn. He has a very neat neck and the way it's shaped is clean, and has a straight edge (his hair is pretty straight at the back too. He's meticulous about his hair and I noticed that he got it cut for his HTD, so I'm going to assume that he'd at least get a trim for the FRC. Also, Kip doesn't have that curly, fuzzy hair that people get at the nape of their neck, it looks like Ed get's it, and probably why he tends to wear his a bit longer at the back. Reid has that kind of hairline at the back too, so I'd say it's either Ed or Reid before I'd think it was Kip.

[dapper22]

The suit photos with floor comparisons.

[albean99]

Originally Posted by stickle

Look at the hands of the blue suit walking. Compare them to the hands of Ed walking out of the Whistler hotel. Bingo. It's a match.

Ed's hand is a little different in how the thumb joins the hand. There's a sc from Ed and Jillian's chat last week that really shows it. His little finger also kind of sticks out a bit. Anyone want to pull up the three sc's to compare?

I agree that the hands are a match. When you watch the video of Ed walking out of the Whistler hotel you can see his thumbs curve up a little and you can really see it in the right hand of blue suit guy. I also see the same stride. I think height can be deceptive because the camera is looking down at the legs and the rail height isn't conclusive at all. I really think it's Ed there and in the doorway but is too tall for hugging guy. One of the shots is the guy standing up straight and he's not nearly as tall as Ed. Valen posted some hairline photos of Kip that seemed to be a match and the height is right. To me it seems that Ed and Kip are the f2. It's possible that the f3 comes back to propose so can't rule it out however I think it's a fakeout and unlikely that a 3rd guy will come back. I also think it's very unlikely that Ed is f3 and comes back because he already came back after leaving on his own so can't imagine coming back after Jillian rejected him.

I have a feeling that the previews of the FRC will change and possibly back off this scenario. The latest commercial talks about "the most surprising proposal in Bachelorette history". Probably more hype but could almost be anything other than the normal f1 proposal.

[Mike'sgirl]

Originally Posted by northernviewer

I've always thought that brown suit hugging guy is bending over to hug her, it's always reminded me of the sc of Ed and Jillian hugging in the fountain. Also, when I look at the hairline of the guy, I think the one guy that I can rule out is Kiptyn. He has a very neat neck and the way it's shaped is clean, and has a straight edge (his hair is pretty straight at the back too. He's meticulous about his hair and I noticed that he got it cut for his HTD, so I'm going to assume that he'd at least get a trim for the FRC. Also, Kip doesn't have that curly, fuzzy hair that people get at the nape of their neck, it looks like Ed get's it, and probably why he tends to wear his a bit longer at the back. Reid has that kind of hairline at the back too, so I'd say it's either Ed or Reid before I'd think it was Kip.

Brown suit guy walking might be Reid..... for whatever reason he is there. Might be in F2, or is an F3 returning. But, that brown suit guy in hugging SC with the bad sewing on the shoulder deserves to be Wes. Now - did they mix the SC of 2 guys in to confuse? I have no idea.

It is entirely possible that all of the F3 and Wes end up at the FRC. Sort of the more drama the better. Although, even if I was there, and saw Reid, Kip or Ed in that hugging SC with the terrible sewing on the suit shoulder - I would not believe it.

[EddieSpaghetty]

Originally Posted by dapper22

The suit photos with floor comparisons.

excellent pics...I agree w/the poster who said their brother was a photographer...the 'brown' version of the suit walking on the blue tile looks photoshopped. also, look at the color of those shoes in that pic...that is NOT a true brown color (looks more like gold 'Dancing with the Stars' tap shoes!!)- The colors were definitely messed with. I still say the suit is blue with brown leather shoes - both accounts are Ed, same hands, same stride, same exact shoes he wore exiting the bldg. when he left for the first time.

I have no idea who the brown suit guy (true brown suit) walking on the salmon colored tile is.

[Alexxxx]

Originally Posted by northernviewer

I've always thought that brown suit hugging guy is bending over to hug her, it's always reminded me of the sc of Ed and Jillian hugging in the fountain. Also, when I look at the hairline of the guy, I think the one guy that I can rule out is Kiptyn. He has a very neat neck and the way it's shaped is clean, and has a straight edge (his hair is pretty straight at the back too. He's meticulous about his hair and I noticed that he got it cut for his HTD, so I'm going to assume that he'd at least get a trim for the FRC. Also, Kip doesn't have that curly, fuzzy hair that people get at the nape of their neck, it looks like Ed get's it, and probably why he tends to wear his a bit longer at the back. Reid has that kind of hairline at the back too, so I'd say it's either Ed or Reid before I'd think it was Kip.

I agree about Kip's hairline. It's way too neat and kept very short to the head at the hairline. There's no thickness or fuzziness as you say. ITA has to be Ed or Reid. Based on height, I'd guess Reid.