I do to think it's Robby. I think he was in Spain and then cut after, which would fit in the time line of him getting home in May right before they go to Hawaii. The guy on the bed and the guy on the bike, his hair is darker than Jillians, and it also seems to have some curl or wave to it. Ed's is straight. Also the way this guy dresses in these SC looks similar to Robby, and the bike guy isn't wearing a watch. Consistant of Robby. Ed wears a large silver band watch with a large black face. Not to mention reports of Ed being home in mid April, which would line up in the time frame of him leaving in Canada, right? I think the girlfriend thing and Ed leaving was the drama that Jillian had to deal with. We don't seem to have a SC of Robby's HTD, but that's not unheard of. I think Robby's storyline will grow this next episode, with him getting the rose on the JWD.