Why would anyone pick the guy who jumped ship (ED)?? Here's a spoiler: Jill isn't as naive as some people think. Once burned - twice learned!
I remember in all the interviews that Jillian did right after fliming ended, she would always say that she hopes people will still like her when F1 is revealed. I guess she is worried that people won't like the fact that she let Ed return to the show, and ultimately becomes F1.
Just my thoughts!!!