Bachelorette 5 Sleuthing Thread **SPOILERS**

[Jojo47]

Originally Posted by wgschlenker

That's a thought. If they truly want us to believe that Reid is done, then why isn't he at the MTA? Damn, and I was just getting pretty confident that Reid comes back to propose and they ride off into the sunset. Then maybe I could relax for the next 2 weeks instead of being a slave to the boards! Any thoughts on why he's not at the MTA. The average, nonsleuther, might get suspicious if he's not there

It would be waaaaay to risky to have Reid at the MTA. All you have to do is watch is Departed video on the alphabet board. He all but says that he'll be coming back. Reid just isn't an actor and wears his heart on his sleeve - there is no way he could be kept under wraps the way he'd need to be on that set.

[Google]

 

[Alanna]

Originally Posted by Jojo47

It would be waaaaay to risky to have Reid at the MTA. All you have to do is watch is Departed video on the alphabet board. He all but says that he'll be coming back. Reid just isn't an actor and wears his heart on his sleeve - there is no way he could be kept under wraps the way he'd need to be on that set.

Exactly. Esp since the F3 gets to grill the B'ette about why he was dumped when in reality, they're probably dating right now and will either announce an engagement or are planning on one eventually. It would just be so weird for both of them for Reid to give her a hard time at the MTA and then go back to some hotel room with her--I bet he finds that little white nightie hot and won't pass out

[wgschlenker]

Originally Posted by Alanna

Exactly. Esp since the F3 gets to grill the B'ette about why he was dumped when in reality, they're probably dating right now and will either announce an engagement or are planning on one eventually. It would just be so weird for both of them for Reid to give her a hard time at the MTA and then go back to some hotel room with her--I bet he finds that little white nightie hot and won't pass out

Ok, you're both probably right!! Thanks for keeping the spirits up! And I'm SURE that he still wants to "make out". God he's adorable

[Miss_Griss]

Originally Posted by slpnm

I totally agree with this. SO MUCH of last night's episode seemed scripted to me (and badly acted at parts) and Reid could barely keep from laughing when he's getting into the limo. I know people deal with grief in different ways but still...

I think they probably had to drive around for hours in the limo because they weren't getting good enough shots of Reid "grieving". They knew the whole ending of the show counts on getting a good narrative of Reid being devastated and realizing he made a huge mistake so it's plausible that he would come back. He doesn't strike me as a good actor so I'm thinking it took awhile until TPTB were sure they had enough film that would provide what they needed.

And EVERYTHING with Ed seemed SO scripted last night. Even some of what Jillian was saying, especially in the interview outside before they go meet his parents, sounded completely like someone had written it for her. Didn't sound like her at all - it might have even had proper grammar!

Well, that's a dead giveaway that it was scripted!

The funny thing is that Ed and Reid are grammatically compatible with her.

I thought her crying scene after Reid left seemed fake. I didn't see one actual tear.

[Brendaavon]

Originally Posted by galgal

Oh my heck! I'm so glad someone else heard the muffled, "I love you" !!!! I think I've watched their goodbye 40 times now. I think I'm starting to hear crazy things in their sighs. But I'm almost sure Jilli says "I can't say goodbye to you," but it's been muffled down to sound like "sigh- say goodbye -sigh" I'm also thinking there is a lot of FAKE exaggerated breathing....let's make this as dramatic as possible.

Oh my!!! I have listened over and over I don't hear the I love you,but did think I heard "I can't say goodbye" or something to that effect it is sliced up I can tell that! So glad I'm not alone hearing that!!!

[SJR]

I Heard reid say I love you! When they were on the bench and his head rested on her, watched it over and over and I totally heard it!!

[wgschlenker]

Originally Posted by SJR

I Heard reid say I love you! When they were on the bench and his head rested on her, watched it over and over and I totally heard it!!

Everyone says it's Jill that says it, but I was wondering if it could have been Reid.

[Love-this-show]

:I am really nervous now b/c I just read an article, "The Bachelorette Finale Spoilers Supposedly Leaked Online"
July 14, 2009 by Robert Dougherty. The writer said the spoiler rumors are running rampant that Jill picks Ed even AFTER Reid confesses his love for her. Could this show and Jillian be that cruel to allow Reid to be shot down twice? I don't think my heart could take much more of Reid hurting - and I don't think his could either. Can anyone confirm that this is absolutely NOT true? Please, please - for my Honeybear?

[wgschlenker]

Originally Posted by Love-this-show

:I am really nervous now b/c I just read an article, "The Bachelorette Finale Spoilers Supposedly Leaked Online"
July 14, 2009 by Robert Dougherty. The writer said the spoiler rumors are running rampant that Jill picks Ed even AFTER Reid confesses his love for her. Could this show and Jillian be that cruel to allow Reid to be shot down twice? I don't think my heart could take much more of Reid hurting - and I don't think his could either. Can anyone confirm that this is absolutely NOT true? Please, please - for my Honeybear?

Noooooooooooooooooo!

[Holls]

Originally Posted by SJR

I Heard reid say I love you! When they were on the bench and his head rested on her, watcd it over and over and I totally heard it!!

whew! 8 thought I was hearing things. It is right after he music gets kind of loud!I thought it was wishful thinking!