Bachelorette 5 Sleuthing Thread **SPOILERS**

[daryos@msn.com]

Originally Posted by Flori da

Are you saying then that she tells her F1 this after she lets the F2 go or before? Then it's thought that it's Ed who proposes because he was the one who was hard to let go in Canada and at what point does that happen? Just trying to put what you've said into perspective.

So, if that's the case then Reid is F1. Because he said in that PI that she seemed confused. Maybe, that's where that comes from, but in the end she picks Reid her first F1.

[Google]

 

[RacingGirl]

Originally Posted by nd4reality

If Kiptyn does walk away at the F2 spot - he would have known he was not the chosen one in advance. He would have seen / felt her pulling away from him in the end (and we will see this too IMO).

I can almost feel a sad vibe to the surfboard scene (both in the water and on shore). Doubt they had mikes out there in the water but the whole scene screamed "parting" to me.

I agree, it looks kinda sad to me as well. Maybe he can sense her pulling away or maybe he is pulling away. I don't know.

[emusha]

Originally Posted by xseannax

. Nice catch there. We have pretty much narrowed down that Ed and Kip will be in the same hotel in Maui, which would explain the lamps.

We narrowed it down to Ed on the bed because of this:
-The guy on the bed and the guy closing the shutters are 2 different room types, which means 2 different guys
-The shutter guy clip was show in the premiere episode on May 18th
-Ed's FD wasn't until the 16th, so that would be a fast turnaround to get footage of his date in, thus eliminating him as the shutter guy
-Reid is seen in a bathtub with Jillian that has been matched to a different hotel meaning he is not shutter or bed guy
-Process of elimination put Ed as bed guy

Thanks for this summary!

Was Reid's room/bathroom matched to a hotel in Hawaii? I thought the tub scene was from Spain. How about the scene with both Jill and (I think) Reid in white bathrobes?

Thank you!

[albean99]

Originally Posted by daryos@msn.com

So, if that's the case then Reid is F1. Because he said in that PI that she seemed confused. Maybe, that's where that comes from, but in the end she picks Reid her first F1.

I know others think that's Reid but I hear Ed saying it because of the way the guy pronounced "confused" which sounds exactly like Ed's accent.

[xseannax]

Originally Posted by emusha

Thanks for this summary!

Was Reid's room/bathroom matched to a hotel in Hawaii? I thought the tub scene was from Spain. How about the scene with both Jill and (I think) Reid in white bathrobes?

Thank you!

The bathrobe scene where you see both Jillian and Reid in robes in a room is in Spain. (F4)

The one where they are standing in a bathtub in surrounded by orchids bathing suits is in Maui. (F3)

[pattycake92]

Or maybe she's confused cause the romance wasn't there for them in Hawaii? I think it's def. Reid that says she's confused.

[emusha]

Originally Posted by xseannax

The bathrobe scene where you see both Jillian and Reid in robes in a room is in Spain. (F4)

The one where they are standing in a bathtub in surrounded by orchids bathing suits is in Maui. (F3)

wow thanks for that information! this makes me more certain it is not reid. has anyone checked the sc where jilly is getting a massage from a guy in cargo shorts as a possible match with the 'performance issue in the bedroom'? would that be ed as well?

[pattycake92]

I don't think the guy giving her an oily massage is the one with the bedroom problem. Looks like they are having a great time to me

[Brendaavon]

Originally Posted by daryos@msn.com

So, if that's the case then Reid is F1. Because he said in that PI that she seemed confused. Maybe, that's where that comes from, but in the end she picks Reid her first F1.

OK am I missing something?? I know I heard Reid say that she seems confused at the htd rc,after borrowing Michael to talk and the the guys are like wah?! Can anyone back that up I can watch it again.

[Earthlygoddess]

Originally Posted by albean99

I know others think that's Reid but I hear Ed saying it because of the way the guy pronounced "confused" which sounds exactly like Ed's accent.

I agree, I think the VO's are from Ed! The accent is very clear with Ed's accent!