Bachelorette 5 Sleuthing Thread **SPOILERS**

[anders332]

Originally Posted by lisamill36

I think that wording is just to throw people off. There will be three guys there and she will probably select one of the three at the actual show so they other two will be there to confront her. I dont think that tells us who the two guys would be

I think the fact that we now have actual pics of the guys AT the FRC we can throw out the idea that she selects someone on the AFRC.

[Google]

 

[chopstickchick]

Originally Posted by lisamill36

I think that wording is just to throw people off. There will be three guys there and she will probably select one of the three at the actual show so they other two will be there to confront her. I dont think that tells us who the two guys would be

so do you think it's a matter of selecting 1 of the 3 at the ATFR, or she ends it with 2 at FRC and leaves it open with 1, and then they confirm if they're giving it a go at ATFR? I'm so confused. Because she does say "she knew it could only be 1 person"

[atem]

Originally Posted by lisamill36

I think that wording is just to throw people off. There will be three guys there and she will probably select one of the three at the actual show so they other two will be there to confront her. I dont think that tells us who the two guys would be

Why do you think that when she said that there is a twist at the end of the last 5 min when you think she picks no one...do you have something clue wise to say what happens, or this is just a guess?

[sanlee]

Originally Posted by thetinydancer

This is really interesting. What has the wording been on past AFTR descriptions? Anyone remember?

They use the same wording every season. They always say that the Final 2 rejectee confronts The Bachelor or The Bachelorette on the ATFR Show.

[sanlee]

Originally Posted by lisamill36

I think that wording is just to throw people off. There will be three guys there and she will probably select one of the three at the actual show so they other two will be there to confront her. I dont think that tells us who the two guys would be

Are you saying that all 3 of the guys will be there and she will have to choose between all 3 of them?

My guess is Reid will be there with Jillian as the happy couple and Kip and Ed will also be there to confront Jillian. When they word it that way, to confront her, it's just their typical way of describing it, imo. They use the same wording every season it seems like.

[aktx]

Ok, this is just a wild guess....I am a huge Reid fan. So, I checked his twitter and I notice there are no tweets between Mar 23 and May 28. I think that indicates that he was in Hawaii until the FRC. This is pure speculation. Also, IMO, since the FRC photo of Ed and Jillian shows the box in his hand, she has to have already have been proposed to and obviously (to me) says no. If the wet pant leg of Kip is accurate and he went down on bended knee and she said no, then she would end up with no one....Until she steps back into the house and sees Reid coming toward her and CH....Oh, I can dream, can't I.

[wing]

Originally Posted by aktx

Ok, this is just a wild guess....I am a huge Reid fan. So, I checked his twitter and I notice there are no tweets between Mar 23 and May 28. I think that indicates that he was in Hawaii until the FRC. This is pure speculation. Also, IMO, since the FRC photo of Ed and Jillian shows the box in his hand, she has to have already have been proposed to and obviously (to me) says no. If the wet pant leg of Kip is accurate and he went down on bended knee and she said no, then she would end up with no one....Until she steps back into the house and sees Reid coming toward her and CH....Oh, I can dream, can't I.

You can dream -- it is allowed! But I completely missed the wet pant leg thing

[thetinydancer]

Originally Posted by sanlee

They use the same wording every season. They always say that the Final 2 rejectee confronts The Bachelor or The Bachelorette on the ATFR Show.

But do they say 2 men confront the Bachelorette?

Originally Posted by aktx

Also, IMO, since the FRC photo of Ed and Jillian shows the box in his hand, she has to have already have been proposed to and obviously (to me) says no.

I agree with this. *If* it is a ring box, no way would he just be holding it in his hand before the proposal. It would be in his pocket or something, I'd think.

I also don't think that it's the old rose, as some have suggested. It would be too delicate to just squish between two hands.

[sanlee]

Originally Posted by thetinydancer

But do they say 2 men confront the Bachelorette?

Nope. Usually they say something about the happy couple being there and then the F2 confronting The Bachelor or The Bachelorette because the Final 3 gets to confront The Bach/Bachelorette at the Men Tell All. Since Reid won't be at the Men Tell All, he will probably be at the ATFR Show.

I assumed your post about the description for the ATFR was referring to the wording (confronting.) Were you actually talking about the wording, (2 spurned bachelors confront Jill.) ?