What's up with that edit??!! - Page 237

dodie430 · 02-13-2009, 12:20 PM

[quote=anders332;3319858;]

Quote:

Originally Posted by ZulaMay

You know what - I won't feel tricked at all...Mel has been getting a chemistry edit that rarely goes to F1, there's been so many red flags with her edit, I've wondered how she CAN be F1.....the problem always lies in the fact that viewers fall in love with someone and feel betrayed if she's not their F1.

Agreed. I kept thinking and hearing from others "Maybe next episode"... I haven't seen her as F1 material, and her edit has sort of boggled me. That's not saying she isn't - only that they did a poor job of conveying it imo.

Google · Sponsored Links

Cornfritter · 02-13-2009, 12:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dodie430

But see that's your perspective [and other Mel fans]. He hasn't led me to believe anything of the sort. I assume Melissa is F1 simply because of the SCs. If I was a casual viewer I'd say all three ladies are on about equal footing, with Jillian a bit ahead by virtue of her HTD. So it's not fact, it's perspective. And a lady's "emotional investment" doesn't matter to the outcome, remember Hilary? And how can you say she's more invested than the other two? No two people convey their emotions the same way, so just because Melissa's bawls and gushes, doesn't mean she's more emotionally invested than the others [not that it would matter if she were].

So as far as being led on, whether Melissa or the viewers, it's all a matter of what you see. I'm sure Mel fans would be ticked, but people who have Molly or Jillian as their fave wouldn't. And people without a fave wouldn't give a hoot. And because they are all great girls, the casual viewer probably won't care much either, beyond "Ohhh I thought he'd pick this one or that one."

Anyway, jmo.

ITA, I am a Mel fan but I do see the connections with Jillian & Molly. The only reason I would be disappointed is because of the screen caps, indicates Melissa as F1.

atem · 02-13-2009, 12:22 PM

[quote=dodie430;3319977;]

Quote:

Originally Posted by anders332

Agreed. I kept thinking and hearing from others "Maybe next episode"... I haven't seen her as F1 material, and her edit has sort of boggled me. That's not saying she isn't - only that they did a poor job of conveying it imo.

That's my take.

Oh, and heads up...there's a new post by RS.

dodie430 · 02-13-2009, 12:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cornfritter

ITA, I am a Mel fan but I do see the connections with Jillian & Molly. The only reason I would be disappointed is because of the screen caps, indicates Melissa as F1.

Thank you for this. Enlightening and insightful

fan*addict · 02-13-2009, 12:25 PM

[quote=atem;3319979;]

Quote:

Originally Posted by dodie430

That's my take.

Oh, and heads up...there's a new post by RS.

And was does the serpant say this morning?

anders332 · 02-13-2009, 12:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dodie430

But see that's your perspective [and other Mel fans]. He hasn't led me to believe anything of the sort. I assume Melissa is F1 simply because of the SCs. If I was a casual viewer I'd say all three ladies are on about equal footing, with Jillian a bit ahead by virtue of her HTD. So it's not fact, it's perspective. And a lady's "emotional investment" doesn't matter to the outcome, remember Hilary? And about Melissa being more invested than the other two - No two people convey their emotions the same way, so just because Melissa's bawls and gushes, doesn't mean she's more emotionally invested than the others [not that it would matter if she were].

So as far as being led on, whether Melissa or the viewers, it's all a matter of what you see. I'm sure Mel fans would be ticked, but people who have Molly or Jillian as their fave wouldn't. And people without a fave wouldn't give a hoot. And because they are all great girls, the casual viewer probably won't care much either, beyond "Ohhh I thought he'd pick this one or that one."

Anyway, jmo.

I just made this very point in another thread - just because Molly isn't all over Jason and being all whiney and clingy doesn't mean that they don't have a great connection.

anders332 · 02-13-2009, 12:35 PM

[quote=fan*addict;3319986;]

Quote:

Originally Posted by atem

And was does the serpant say this morning?

pretty much that all these theories that everyone has suggested are completely false and no where near the truth.......

and this

“It’s not about the who, but the how”

BachfanNY · 02-13-2009, 12:39 PM

[quote=anders332;3320005;]

Quote:

Originally Posted by fan*addict

pretty much that all these theories that everyone has suggested are completely false and no where near the truth.......

and this

“It’s not about the who, but the how”

That' what a lot of us have been thinking.

Minney · 02-13-2009, 12:40 PM

[quote=BachfanNY;3320009;]

Quote:

Originally Posted by anders332

That' what a lot of us have been thinking.

He also backed off or clarified his statements about the scriptedness of the show.

gotcharunnin1 · 02-13-2009, 01:04 PM

he says there's 2 or 3 degrees of seperation. That NOONE has picked up on what he has written but if we go back and read all that he has wrote someone should pick up on it.

2/3 has two meanings.
I think 1 is the 2 or 3 degrees of seperation.....

and noone has guessed the 2/3 clues or montreal

02-13-2009, 01:04 PM	#2370
gotcharunnin1 FORT Fan Join Date: Apr 2007 Posts: 236	Re: What's up with that edit??!! he says there's 2 or 3 degrees of seperation. That NOONE has picked up on what he has written but if we go back and read all that he has wrote someone should pick up on it. 2/3 has two meanings. I think 1 is the 2 or 3 degrees of seperation..... and noone has guessed the 2/3 clues or montreal