Part 2: "Spoilers & Screencap Analysis ONLY" **SPOILERS** - Bachelor 12

[twochicklets]

Thanks Lynn7, that is just what I needed! Sorry KashattheDiva, I was just trying to focus on the other photo, there is nothing new to look at, so I just wanted to look at something we had in a different way.

[Google]

 

[Kresge]

Okay, super duper screencap post. It's Chelsea in both shots.

I can't remember who posted these first two but they did an excellent job of comparing items in both rooms.
http://i301.photobucket.com/albums/nn73/Lynn71965/Chelseacircles1.jpg
http://i301.photobucket.com/albums/nn73/Lynn71965/Chelseacircles.jpg

These are the ones that I put together to show the comparison of jawline and arms. Notice the muscular indentation in the forearm of Chelsea in the clip with the large blue line. It matches the girl attacking Matt on the couch




These are Amanda's. There is no muscle indentation in her forearm.

What you see as a muscle indentation on the couch girl just looks like a bone to me......Amanda has the same thing, Chelsea has a bone and some muscle.

I do think they are both Chelsea......there is no way Matt is wearing the same clothes, on the same couch, in the same suite, drinking from a champagne bottle sitting in the same place, with 2 different girls who just happen to have on black dresses with spaghetti straps.

While the prone pic does resemble Amanda, they HAVE to be the same girl, and the sitting pic is clearly Chelsea.......that jawline just doesn't lie.(imo)

[soccermama]

Originally Posted by KashatheDiva

I don't want this to come across wrong--remember it's TGIF and past cocktail hour on the east coast--BUT---this has been done ad nauseum in several threads.

There is one camp that believes these scs are Chelsea. End of subject.

There is another that can not accept it and won't be happy until until they see it on tv--they still think one is Amanda and one is Chelsea.

Have fun investigating!

Well, it's only Thursday in Chicago, but I wish it was Friday, lol!!

[KashatheDiva]

Originally Posted by soccermama

Well, it's only Thursday in Chicago, but I wish it was Friday, lol!!

Oh lordy!!!
Until I just read your post- an hour later--I thought it was FRIDAY evening!
Ok--well good excuse to have some wine 2 nights in a row then!!!
(it seriously was only 1 glass too!)

[n4692u]

Did anyone notice the VO of Amanda's when she and Matt were in the pool talking about "rednecks", "trailers" and "possum Monday night 4/14 (Ep. 5)?
It SHOWED her talking about getting alone time and getting a HTD, but this was a vo and sounded different and does not fit her current circumstances.


QUOTE: "...haven't really had any time with him except for the first date, so I'm not sure that we have enough of a connection for him to keep me around."


Supposedly, when Amanda said that, she, Shayne and Holly were the only ones who had had solo dates with him and Marshana having alone time on the 2/1 after Matt sent Holly home. Chelsea had her first 1/1 date in Idaho just prior to the date Amanda was currently on (Skiing & Spa w/Shayne, Robin & Marshana). Amanda got TWO alone time's with him on this date; Matt teaching her to ski AND in the pool. Of course the last 1/1 date in Idaho the other night was Noelle. Robin got her solo time by stealing him from every other girl in the house (past & present) during their alone time during group dates and before RC's.

What I'm clumsily trying to say is, I don't think she said that in Idaho and I think she was really talking about "the first date" which was the modelling date in the 2nd episode. What do ya think?

I actually think this past espisode (5), TPTB have maybe begun to bring Amanda out of hiding with the two alone times with Matt on one group date. Also, we know he kissed her before the RC (Photo), but they did not show it in the Monday's episode because they put the above "statement" in her PI to put doubt on who would get the 4th rose because it was pretty obvious that the other three were going to get roses. The Shayne show seemed to subside a little. I think that the Shayne snow/makeup scene might have been staged. It WAS cute though. I also think Matt's VO "your kisses are amazing" (showing he & Shayne in a snowlift) was NOT said to Shayne. Those kisses between Matt and Amanda looked pretty hot to me to warrant that statement.

I just hope and pray that they are bringing her forward because I am certainly rooting for her. I hope that statement about a connection isn't preparing us for F3. I just hope her HTD prank turns out ok. Can't wait to see it. I think they have a great connection as do the girls who have left the house who have given interviews, but I haven't read them all by a long shot.

I'm fully trusting CH, so therefore I am expecting a "British Gentleman and An All American Girl" (who just happened to have gotten the FIR) to be the last ones standing at the FRC.

Sorry, I get carried away.

[Mamai]

I'm a big Amanda Fan, so I was really convinced that this was Amanda, and somehow the sitting pic was Amanda too or a fake. But after lightening this picture a lot, I think it's Chelsea. I can finally see the highlights in the hair in the front of her head. I think Chelsea has a lot of highlights in the front and not so much in the back, therefore it looked dark.

I was hoping it was Amanda...



Edited to add it cropped more:

[JoLena]

Here's the arm comparison but this time I'm using only Amanda's arms. I had to flip a couple of shots because I couldn't find a good left arm shot for her so some of these are her right arm but the shape is essentially the same.

http://i301.photobucket.com/albums/nn73/Lynn71965/Amandaarmcomparison.jpg

Gee , the arms look like a match to me. IF you notice Amanda's hair in the pic on the bottom , she does have streaks in it too. Oh God, could it be? Maybe we need to pull the photo's back up and check out the profile of the girls face a little better.

[FanOfUnrealTV]

Chelsea's hair has a LOT of highlighting. Is it dark enough that it could practically blend into a black dress or that strands or her hair could be mistaken for straps on her dress?

[Capegal]

Originally Posted by bachlorfan

Gee , the arms look like a match to me. IF you notice Amanda's hair in the pic on the bottom , she does have streaks in it too. Oh God, could it be? Maybe we need to pull the photo's back up and check out the profile of the girls face a little better.

BACHLORFAN - just look at that jaw line in your avatar
uuuuummmmmmmm

[JoLena]

Originally Posted by Capegal

BACHLORFAN - just look at that jaw line in your avatar
uuuuummmmmmmm

Thanks Cape .. lol