Part 2: "Spoilers & Screencap Analysis ONLY" **SPOILERS** - Bachelor 12

[Lynn7]

I love your reasoning Casualfan. If this SC is indeed from the 6/4 RC, then it has to be Noelle granted you believe that the horse ride SC is Noelle.
Also I know that Noelle and Robin hair color could look the same sometimes but you would at least expect to see Robin's hair match Matt's and that's not the case here. I truly believe that the "coat girl" is Noelle but I'm not 100% sure like I am for the horse ride SC.

I'm bringing this over from the horseback riding thread; affectionately known as the cow thread.

So, back to the topic. If, in fact, the girl isn't Noelle, but Amanda, then who is our F4? I hope this comparison is as conclusive as it is to me. As with Amanda, I flipped Noelle's photo to provide a better angle. It looks like a slam dunk for it to be Amanda...arggh!

[pbmax]

I think beside the dimples Noelle has very fair skin. Amanda & Robin are more similar in skin tone. So in saying that I re-watched epis 3 and one big difference between them are their eyebrows - Robin very thin and Amanda's are fuller but short. I can see eyebrows on the girl in question. My thought was if it was Robin you would not be able to see eyebrows. Since Amanda's are fuller you could. In this picture I can see some eyebrows.

Also, if you watch Robin her hair is usually behind her ear 99% of the time and would not even touch the jacket in the back. Look at her hair in eps 3 while talking with Matt and hair is wet and in the hot tub her hair is layered and would not easily be able to be caught by the jacket. JMO I believe it is Amanda.

That is Robin in that sc. That is her head and it doesn't look anything like Amanda. That person is shorter than Amanda, she would come a little higher up to Matt. Robin has her head/shoulder drawn downward, is why her hair is under the coat. Like Lynn said, he's not even into that kiss.

[nennie]

I'm bringing this over from the horseback riding thread; affectionately known as the cow thread.

So, back to the topic. If, in fact, the girl isn't Noelle, but Amanda, then who is our F4? I hope this comparison is as conclusive as it is to me. As with Amanda, I flipped Noelle's photo to provide a better angle. It looks like a slam dunk for it to be Amanda...arggh!

I think it's Amanda too.

[Lynn7]

Have you matched up the tie he wore that night and the one in this picture?

We've been trying to match up candles, flowers, suits and ties in the Candles thread...in case anyone is interested

[momoutoftime]

I'm bringing this over from the horseback riding thread; affectionately known as the cow thread.

So, back to the topic. If, in fact, the girl isn't Noelle, but Amanda, then who is our F4? I hope this comparison is as conclusive as it is to me. As with Amanda, I flipped Noelle's photo to provide a better angle. It looks like a slam dunk for it to be Amanda...arggh!

Thanks for the pictures.. I agree it's Amanda

[muslady]

The tie in the kissing photo is different than shown for this upcoming week. The tie in the kissing photo is stripped and the one for this coming week has white diamond shapes on it. The SHIRT is the same, but the ties are different. The coat kissing girl is wearing doesn't look to have pinstripes either.


How about we look at the kissing girl's nails. Can we find a cap of Noelle's nails and Robin's nails. Upon close inspection, The kissing girl has squared nails that are either a shiny polish or white polish... Robin bites her nails and the nail size looks to match.

Robin doesn't look like she bites her nails but they are short because they need to be short to play piano and violin, which she does. I think the "muscularness" (for lack of a better word) from playing makes her hand look thicker as well. Noelle has slimmer hands and fingers. JMO

[Lynn7]

Robin doesn't look like she bites her nails but they are short because they need to be short to play piano and violin, which she does. I think the "muscularness" (for lack of a better word) from playing makes her hand look thicker as well. Noelle has slimmer hands and fingers. JMO

I've played piano and violin pretty much my whole life and I almost always have long nails...except when there were newborns around that I worried I would scratch one by accident.

[Tiger Pride Mom]

here

WOW! If there was ever a screencap to show why we've had so much trouble with the similarities in hair between Amanda and Noelle, THIS is IT!

[redrose]

I'm bringing this over from the horseback riding thread; affectionately known as the cow thread.

So, back to the topic. If, in fact, the girl isn't Noelle, but Amanda, then who is our F4? I hope this comparison is as conclusive as it is to me. As with Amanda, I flipped Noelle's photo to provide a better angle. It looks like a slam dunk for it to be Amanda...arggh!

WOW, this is very convincing to me that horse girl is Amanda.

...bringing back memories of pink backpack girl... who I was convinced was Danielle until I saw the episode!

[Lynn7]

WOW, this is very convincing to me that horse girl is Amanda.

...bringing back memories of pink backpack girl... who I was convinced was Danielle until I saw the episode!

Thank heavens for small mercies...someone has finally come forward and confirmed that it is Noelle on the horse. She makes F4.

I'm with you...the piggyback is a dead ringer for Amanda; right down to the dimples at the base of her back.

Horseback riding girl looked like Noelle but when you do the comparison it can go either way.

No more cow dreams for me