Part 2: "Spoilers & Screencap Analysis ONLY" **SPOILERS** - Bachelor 12

[luv4dummies]

Originally Posted by Capegal

Chelsea is really slouching alot in the F3 pic - Shayne is wearing heals

I told you she has a wedgy geesh!

[Google]

 

[Bet2Win]

Thanks Dodie !!!

[luv4dummies]

Originally Posted by Bet2Win

I'm a lawyer, and have watched a lot of hands going for their pocketbooks

Shayne's hands

Now that is one way to analyze hands going for the credit cards I presume LOL

[dodie430]

Originally Posted by Capegal

Chelsea is really slouching alot in the F3 pic - Shayne is wearing heals

I wouldn't say slouching alot - a bit of a tilt yes, but at best if she straightened up - she'd be equal in heighth. Even if she were 1/2 inch taller than Shayne after straightening up - my point is that just because some people say that the Sunset Girl must be Shayne because she's engulfed by Matt - doesn't mean it could not equally be Chelsea. And the F3 SC demonstrates that imo.

If it is said that the Sunset Girl must be Shayne because the Ring Hand belongs to Shayne (which I don't necessarily agree or disagree with) - then that would simply be an assumption. If it's the heighth, I think it could be either.

[Capegal]

Originally Posted by dodie430

I wouldn't say slouching alot - a bit of a tilt yes, but at best if she straightened up - she'd be equal in heighth. Even if she were 1/2 inch taller than Shayne after straightening up - my point is that just because some people say that the Sunset Girl must be Shayne because she's engulfed by Matt - doesn't mean it could not equally be Chelsea. And the F3 SC demonstrates that imo.

If it is said that the Sunset Girl must be Shayne because the Ring Hand belongs to Shayne (which I don't necessarily agree or disagree with) - then that would simply be an assumption. If it's the heighth, I think it could be either.

I can also see that sunset pic being Amanda as well - leaning back against him with her head tilted a bit to the side - she could still be hidden behind him - but that is just me

[KareyR2]

I'm still not convinced. If that arm belongs to Shayne then where is the bulge just above the elbow?
http://i301.photobucket.com/albums/nn73/Lynn71965/Finalgirlelbowcomparison1.jpg
http://i301.photobucket.com/albums/nn73/Lynn71965/FRCsunsetflippedelbowcompariso n.jpg
http://i301.photobucket.com/albums/nn73/Lynn71965/Finalgirlelbowcomparison2.jpg

Shayne's elbow is not flexed in the proposal picture, but it is in the sc you pointed out....thus you see her bicep flexed....not the same look in a nonflexed picture. Thanks
Karey

[cantstopwatchin]

Originally Posted by Capegal

I can also see that sunset pic being Amanda as well - leaning back against him with her head tilted a bit to the side - she could still be hidden behind him - but that is just me

Nope, not just you. I think it could/would happen that way as well. A girl 'in love' wouldn't stand straight up in front of her fiance in that setting. The girl would be leaning against him, thus slouching and losing a couple of inches.

It could still be Amanda...

[dodie430]

Originally Posted by KashatheDiva

Sunset girl "could" be Chelsea but most likely Shayne as Chelsea is still a bit taller.

But not at the F3 she's not, she's actually shorter - or maybe equal in height. Which proves beyond a doubt to me that Sunset Girl could very easily be Chelsea.

I don't have a clue who it is in reality... lol.....I'm just trying to present a different viewpoint that is entirely possible, and back it up with the SC.

[mommadeb]

Personally, I think that all 3 girls and Matt look weird in the one. Look at how tall they make Amanda look. I mean, I know she is taller that Shayne by a few inches, but look how they made her tower over Chelsea. It looks like the picture is distorted and everyone does not look like their real selves.

[mysonisthebest]

Originally Posted by mommadeb

Personally, I think that all 3 girls and Matt look weird in the one. Look at how tall they make Amanda look. I mean, I know she is taller that Shayne by a few inches, but look how they made her tower over Chelsea. It looks like the picture is distorted and everyone does not look like their real selves.

That's why I believe they are lined up as they are.