Part 2: "Spoilers & Screencap Analysis ONLY" **SPOILERS** - Bachelor 12

[luv4dummies]

Originally Posted by Capegal

I have questioned if Amanda has bling on her left arm in that F3 shot - been waiting for someone else to check it out

Well if I could see the darn thing I would help you! Can someone make it bigger get your mind out of the gutter that is where mine is and I was here first

[Google]

 

[cantstopwatchin]

I'm still not convinced. If that arm belongs to Shayne then where is the bulge just above the elbow?
http://i301.photobucket.com/albums/nn73/Lynn71965/Finalgirlelbowcomparison1.jpg
http://i301.photobucket.com/albums/nn73/Lynn71965/FRCsunsetflippedelbowcompariso n.jpg
http://i301.photobucket.com/albums/nn73/Lynn71965/Finalgirlelbowcomparison2.jpg

I'm with ya, Lynn! From the get-go, I've seen Amanda's arm and still continue to see it. (Happy Birthday, btw!)

Everyone is so quick to say Amanda is 5'9" but I would like to point out that I think everyone took my post, saying that I am 5'9" when I compared the proposal to myself and DH and ran with it. Prior to that post, I'd never heard of Amanda being called 5'9". For the record-- Amanda is NOT 5'9". I'd say she's closer to 5'7"-ish.

[Bloomers]

Originally Posted by Capegal

I have questioned if Amanda has bling on her left arm in that F3 shot - been waiting for someone else to check it out

I can't even see it!

[FanOfUnrealTV]

I originally thought she was 5'9" but I think I was deceived by her thin frame, shorter dresses and hiiiiigh heels. I think she is 5'7" also.

[luv4dummies]

Originally Posted by cantstopwatchin

I'm with ya, Lynn! From the get-go, I've seen Amanda's arm and still continue to see it. (Happy Birthday, btw!)

Everyone is so quick to say Amanda is 5'9" but I would like to point out that I think everyone took my post, saying that I am 5'9" when I compared the proposal to myself and DH and ran with it. Prior to that post, I'd never heard of Amanda being called 5'9". For the record-- Amanda is NOT 5'9". I'd say she's closer to 5'7"-ish.

Yeah that is a good way to start a rumor around here! We have too many. I was searching for where it states she is 5 9 and couldn't find it anywhere. I measure like this short, shorter, shortest
I don't see a bulge in the arm at the proposal??? But, I also can't see the SC of the F2 LOL blind as a bat I am.

[Lynn7]

Originally Posted by Bloomers

I can't even see it!

Chelsea appears to have something on both wrists. With Amanda, I think what people are seeing as a possible bracelet, and there very well could be one, is a beam of sun near her upper arm and a pleat from her dress near her wrist. Both seem to be casting a shadow of what looks like a bracelet.

[candimichele]

Originally Posted by Capegal

I have questioned if Amanda has bling on her left arm in that F3 shot - been waiting for someone else to check it out

Well I said I think I see a silver bracelet on her left arm

[dodie430]

Originally Posted by Mike'sgirl

Well, there has been a lot of discussion and SC analysis in these threads. Basically we can see that the girl is completely hidden and Shayne is small enough so that her head would completely be out of view (as which occurs in this shot). Amanda's head would have been seen past his shoulders.

Chelsea is not a bling girl, there are more reasons, but you can check back and review them if your interested.

Yeah, I thought the heighth was the main reason, which is why I don't understand the reasoning behind the only possibility being Shayne. I don't necessarily think that whether or not a girl wears a bracelet or not is though. I wear zero jewellry, but will wear some really nice stuff for important events.

Getting back to the heighth thing....

I've looked at all the SC, and as I've stated previously Shayne has been consistently shorter than Chelsea, with and without heels. The top of Shayne's head comes approx. midway between Matt's armpit and shoulder line when she is not wearing heels and approx. to his shoulder line when she is wearing heels.

The top of Chelsea's head comes approx. to Matt's shoulder line when she's not wearing heels and about mid-neck when she is.

And yet.... Chelsea is seen to be shorter than Shayne at the F3, even with correcting for the little tilt - she might [at best] be as tall as Shayne.

Look at these pics. I've lined up the differences, and corrected for perspective or slouches where necessary. For example, the pic of Shayne and Matt on the tennis court, I've lowered the line to account for his slouch, and the beach - I've adjusted for the top of her hat and the slope of the beach. I am by no means an expert, but did the best I could with my judgement, so please correct me if my eyes are deceiving me, or if I've horribly miscalculated anything.

I'm never too proud to admit when I'm wrong - just love the discussion that goes on here!

[Capegal]

Chelsea is really slouching alot in the F3 pic - Shayne is wearing heals

[Bet2Win]

Originally Posted by KashatheDiva

There are quite a few of us who know our hands.
I've dealt with phlebotomy and iv's for years. I've taught anatomy classes.
No doubt in my mind that those hands/thumbs/fingers/wrists, elbow and shoulders are Shayne's, not to mention that is her in the sunset sc.

I'm a lawyer, and have watched a lot of hands going for their pocketbooks

Shayne's hands