Part 2: "Spoilers & Screencap Analysis ONLY" **SPOILERS** - Bachelor 12

[ohkayk]

Amanda's arms are very slender and in the closeups she has a bone that is prominent just above the wrist. I don't see that bone on the bracelet arm. And it certainly seems to be Shane's shoulder. LOL But what do I know? In the SC of Matt looking at the sunset, I still can't picture the position the F1 is supposedly in. The way Matt's arms are positioned, he would have to have the girl in a chokehold. haha That would make it Shayne alright

[Google]

 

[Lynn7]

Originally Posted by heatheshells10

I think it's because her shoulder has a more defined muscle tone to it than the F1 girl.

That's correct.

Chelsea has very defined shoulders particularly at the top. Hers are round and muscular, not like someone who takes steroids, but defined like that. You can actually see an indentation at the top of her shoulders that eliminates her as F3 because the thumb in that one shot looks to be Shayne's thumb but the shoulder and proposal hand look to be Amanda.

I did another comparison. How anyone can think that this hand looks like Shayne's hand is amazing?

[Bet2Win]

Originally Posted by cupcakes

i think all the clues point to shayne thats why....

1)thumb matches
2)shoulder matches
3)arm matches
4)height matches
5)hand accesories match
6)spoiler from e online that a "flaxen hair" girls wins
7)someone from crew/set stating that shayne is F1
8)developing storyline since day one
9)her having the Great House as fantasy date, whereas the other two are the Hilton
10)early rumors/speculation that shayne was cast to be final 1
11)early on we were told that Matt likes blondes
12)anything else i missed?

Well, if you want to include rumors ... a poster at ihategreenbeans.com said she is a dear friend of Shayne's, and Shayne wins.

I was looking at the latest sc's ... Shayne and Matt at the dinner table in the champagnish dress ... is this a LCD sc? The dress of Shayne and Matt on the bed at the Great House is sleeveless ... the dress at the dinner table appears to have sleeves, or at least the material covers her shoulders.

[Bet2Win]

That's correct.

Chelsea has very defined shoulders particularly at the top. Hers are round and muscular, not like someone who takes steroids, but defined like that. You can actually see an indentation at the top of her shoulders that eliminates her as F3 because the thumb in that one shot looks to be Shayne's thumb but the shoulder and proposal hand look to be Amanda.

I did another comparison. How anyone can think that this hand looks like Shayne's hand is amazing?
http://i301.photobucket.com/albums/nn73/Lynn71965/ProposalhandShaynecomparison1. jpg

Lynn ... look at the sc's on page 1 of the hands thread ... the sc's of Shayne's hands don't have dimples ... and one of the sc's of Amanda's shows a dimple on her hand below her wrist ... so dimples may show up depending on the angle of the hand. I would drag them here, if I knew how.

[catn3d]

Do you have a cap of Shayne where her hand is not bent?

[n4692u]

One more thing and I gotta go to bed. This is in regards to Matt's conversation outside with Chelsea's mom at her HTD. I think part of what was said WAS NOT actually said to her because it makes no sense. I went back & listened to again and want to know what you think.

Said to Chelsea's Mom: "Chelsea, she's outstandingly beautiful, she's genuine, she's smart, VO (I'VE FALLEN IN LOVE WITH HER THE FIRST TIME) I hung out with her & I was gutted because I was starting to feel that maybe she was not into me."

The statement in all caps sounded strange to me. First, it sounded like his tone was different, but the tense didn't match. He should have said this if that's what he actually meant to say.

He should have said "I fell in love with her the first time I hung out with her.

I think he said that to Amanda' dad or S. Can't keep my eyes open. Good night!

[Lynn7]

Originally Posted by n4692u

One more thing and I gotta go to bed. This is in regards to Matt's conversation outside with Chelsea's mom at her HTD. I think part of what was said WAS NOT actually said to her because it makes no sense. I went back & listened to again and want to know what you think.

Said to Chelsea's Mom: "Chelsea, she's outstandingly beautiful, she's genuine, she's smart, VO (I'VE FALLEN IN LOVE WITH HER THE FIRST TIME) I hung out with her & I was gutted because I was starting to feel that maybe she was not into me."

The statement in all caps sounded strange to me. First, it sounded like his tone was different, but the tense didn't match. He should have said this if that's what he actually meant to say.

He should have said "I fell in love with her the first time I hung out with her.

I think he said that to Amanda' dad or S. Can't keep my eyes open. Good night!

You're right. There were three splice ins that I caught and that was one of them. The Monkey comment was another splice in and I can't, for the life of me, remember right now what the third one was.

[Lynn7]

Originally Posted by Bet2Win

Lynn ... look at the sc's on page 1 of the hands thread ... the sc's of Shayne's hands don't have dimples ... and one of the sc's of Amanda's shows a dimple on her hand below her wrist ... so dimples may show up depending on the angle of the hand. I would drag them here, if I knew how.

That's certainly possible. I'm so tired I'm not seeing straight. If nothing else it is something distinct to Shayne's hand. Her dimple is in the meaty part of the hand whereas Amanda's dimple isn't; it's at the wrist bone.

[KareyR2]

Originally Posted by cupcakes

i think all the clues point to shayne thats why....

1)thumb matches
2)shoulder matches
3)arm matches
4)height matches
5)hand accesories match
6)spoiler from e online that a "flaxen hair" girls wins
7)someone from crew/set stating that shayne is F1
8)developing storyline since day one
9)her having the Great House as fantasy date, whereas the other two are the Hilton
10)early rumors/speculation that shayne was cast to be final 1
11)early on we were told that Matt likes blondes
12)matt really likes shayne
13)ihategreenbeans poster claiming that they are shayne's friend and that she is final one
14)anything i missed?

Yes CC...thanks so much for writing out all the variables and adding in the SC evidence that I mentioned above for Shayne being F1....but I was far too lazy to write them all out....and the one you missed was that Matt has the most connection, chemistry and love for Shayne. Thanks again
Karey

[Lynn7]

Originally Posted by Lynn7

That's certainly possible. I'm so tired I'm not seeing straight. If nothing else it is something distinct to Shayne's hand. Her dimple is in the meaty part of the hand whereas Amanda's dimple isn't; it's at the wrist bone.

Sorry to quote myself...it wouldn't let me edit.

I meant to add that the dimple indentations aren't from the right side of the hand. It's more of a comparison of something distinct about Shayne's hand compared to Amanda's hand. In other words, those indentations are from the outside of her hand (pinky) and not the inside (thumb).