Hands, hands and more hands

[OutsideLookinIn]

Originally Posted by Lynn7

Well, Shayne has more of what I would call a 'teenage pudginess' to it still. Chelsea has a very pronounce bump of skin that protrudes from her elbow although it is kind of bony and her forearm is muscular with an indentation. Amanda's arms arm thin and she does have a dimple at the elbow like Shayne does. Chelsea doesn't have that. I think Chelsea is F3.

Thanks Lynn for explaining these to me ...

My gut tells me Amanda is still F1l and that 'shoulder' while he was on his knees gave me more hope .... I actually have Chelsea as my F2 but if that hand is from an F2 then it definitely looked like Shanye's... But... I still think Chelsea is F2

[Google]

 

[Lynn7]

Originally Posted by OutsideLookinIn

Matt's smile and facial expression to me points to Amanda... It's like I've seen him with that kind of facial expression with her before

Thanks Lynn for these SC!

Btw, what's the difference with all F3 elbows???

Well, Shayne has more of what I would call a 'teenage pudginess' to it still. Chelsea has a very pronounce bump of skin that protrudes from her elbow although it is kind of bony and her forearm is muscular with an indentation. Amanda's arms arm thin and she does have a dimple at the elbow like Shayne does. Chelsea doesn't have that. I think Chelsea is F3.

[keg701]

I am losing my mind trying to keep up with all of this. This thread in particular is making me crazy because all I can think of is the book "Hand, hand, fingers, thumb"

[griffen37]

Originally Posted by OutsideLookinIn

Thanks Lynn for explaining these to me ...

My gut tells me Amanda is still F1l and that 'shoulder' while he was on his knees gave me more hope .... I actually have Chelsea as my F2 but if that hand is from an F2 then it definitely looked like Shanye's... But... I still think Chelsea is F2

yeah I think it is amandas shoulder, but whats getting me is the pic of him holding onto a girl looking out into the sunset????? this upsets me because i think it is Shayne, you can see her watch. someone please reassure me that Amanda wins

[mommyof2poodles]

Originally Posted by clmlw

I feel like a horrible mom today because I kept my 11 year old up WAY past her bedtime and made her go over the thumb shot a zillion times with me on DVR! (Can you say OBSESSED?!?!?).

She made a great point that the thumb shown had pale pink polish and a pointy, sort of rounded fingernail. Shayne's nails are squared with pale poolish, Chelsea had dark polish on, and Amanda has pale polish with pointier, rounded nails.

I don't know exactly what it all means, but through the eyes of an 11 year old, she thought for sure it was Amanda.

I know you and I have totally disagreed on Shayne and Amanda but, the hand does look like Shayne's to me. I hate that because I think this whole season is a complete set up. If they think this will bring everyone back on board, they are sadly mistaken.

You should be happy though, so, congratulations on your girl getting the whole prize.

At least my perfect record is still intact. Although Amanda was my and about 60% of the others favorite, I refused to make a pick this season.

[maxkl]

Originally Posted by Cornfritter

ITA, I posted earlier the small dimple in the chosen one's elbow look like Shayne's elbow in post #150 check out her left elbow. Let me know what you think.

Thats what I was looking at, the dimple, thats why I think its Shaynes arm. But I'm not a great sluther either... I would like it to be Amanda's, but I think the F2 are Chelsea and Shayne... I want to be wrong though!

[fan*addict]

Originally Posted by griffen37

yeah I think it is amandas shoulder, but whats getting me is the pic of him holding onto a girl looking out into the sunset????? this upsets me because i think it is Shayne, you can see her watch. someone please reassure me that Amanda wins

I agree...I look at the " proposal" and see Amanda...the other SC in question certainly appears to be Shayne (height observance)

[maxkl]

I've looked at the screen caps, can someone tell me where they think they see the white watch, I just don't see it!!

[CindyBee]

Originally Posted by griffen37

yeah I think it is amandas shoulder, but whats getting me is the pic of him holding onto a girl looking out into the sunset????? this upsets me because i think it is Shayne, you can see her watch. someone please reassure me that Amanda wins

Sorry I can't be the one to reassure you as my feeling for a long time has been that Amanda goes out at final 3. And For me everything screams a Shayne win, including the sunset picture.

Maybe others feel differently.

[RomanticHaze]

Originally Posted by fan*addict

I think that "The Thumb" belongs to Shayne... But I do not think this is the proposal hand...I think this is the "goodbye" hand

This shoulder/arm is the proposal completly different (coloring, structure) it points to Amanda (IMHO) lighter of the 3 ladies....and the sholder height compared to Matt....

Fleiss is giving us just enough to hang ourselves this year...nothing more...nothing less...

If it is the goodbye hand, wouldn't his arm be angled up and not down? It is obvious he is on bended knee.