Hands, hands and more hands

[Cornfritter]

Originally Posted by maxkl

I knew when I went to bed last night that I could wake up this morning to find all the conclusions on the "thumb" sc they gave last night! I think the thumb is Shaynes too, but was hoping for someone elses. Although the blue box in the background could be imposed on the picture too to make us think she's the F1. I like Shayne, just don't think anything with her will last... very young and working on her career, nothing wrong with that... just don't think getting married is really the right thing for her now.

I also think the "arm" is Shaynes as well.

ITA, I posted earlier the small dimple in the chosen one's elbow look like Shayne's elbow in post #150 check out her left elbow. Let me know what you think.

[Google]

 

[AFrankR]

The hand when the VO says "will you marry me" and the shoulder when we see him on his knee saying "I love you" DO NOT MATCH skintone wise, unless lighting and shadow play a GREAT PART.
We're seeing F1 first, and I think it's F2's hand.

Again....JMO.....grab me a towel....could be all wet again........

[Ryvetted]

Originally Posted by fan*addict

I think that "The Thumb" belongs to Shayne... But I do not think this is the proposal hand...I think this is the "goodbye" hand

This shoulder/arm is the proposal completly different (coloring, structure) it points to Amanda (IMHO) lighter of the 3 ladies....and the sholder height compared to Matt....

Fleiss is giving us just enough to hang ourselves this year...nothing more...nothing less...

On Joker's, there's a slow motion video. It looks 99% positive that he is slipping a ring on Shayne's hand. And when he is looking straight ahead at shoulder girl - that shoulder lowers. Like he lifted her and put her down or something...??

[OutsideLookinIn]

Originally Posted by AFrankR

The hand when the VO says "will you marry me" and the shoulder when we see him on his knee saying "I love you" DO NOT MATCH skintone wise, unless lighting and shadow play a GREAT PART.
We're seeing F1 first, and I think it's F2's hand.

Again....JMO.....grab me a towel....could be all wet again........

ITA with you above... The shoulder when he was on his knees doesn't match the hand (skin tone-wise) so you could be right... that hand probably belongs to the F2

[Lynn7]

Originally Posted by ButterflyFaery

I am not sure who the thumb belongs too but everyone seems to feel that it has to be the F1 because of the ring box in the background....BUT..do you know how easy it would be to photoshop in the background around the picture to make it look like something it was not...Fleiss is famous for this kind of stuff

That's why I think it's important to find the matching elbow. Sheesh, me and my elbows this season In the elbow shot he is actually kneeling down to proposse. There's even a cap of her shoulder and it looks to be around the height of Amanda.

[OutsideLookinIn]

That's why I think it's important to find the matching elbow. Sheesh, me and my elbows this season In the elbow shot he is actually kneeling down to proposse. There's even a cap of her shoulder and it looks to be around the height of Amanda.

http://i301.photobucket.com/albums/nn73/Lynn71965/Finalgirlelbow1.jpg
http://i301.photobucket.com/albums/nn73/Lynn71965/Finalgirlelbow.jpg
http://i301.photobucket.com/albums/nn73/Lynn71965/MattFRCwithfinalgirl.jpg
http://i301.photobucket.com/albums/nn73/Lynn71965/MattFRC.jpg

Matt's smile and facial expression to me points to Amanda... It's like I've seen him with that kind of facial expression with her before

Thanks Lynn for these SC!

Btw, what's the difference with all F3 elbows???

Also, with Shayne being the shortest and with Matt on his knees I think he would be more of an eye-level with her in that case right?

[soccermama]

Here is a better cap of Shayne's thumb
http://i105.photobucket.com/albums/m225/nikicolecole/shaynehands.png

One thing that I do notice in this SC, is that Matt is wearing a watch. There has been a lot of speculation that the watch Matt is wearing on the Ellen show was a gift from his F1. But if he was already wearing it here, then it is just his watch...

[Fancygirl]

Originally Posted by BuckeyeGal007

I definitely don't think that the arm is Chelsea's...Chelsea's arm is more toned than than the other two women. I think the arm looks like Amanda (shoulder to elbow length, color, shape) and the hand looks like Shayne. Maybe Fleiss is giving us both the F2 this year. I just don't think that hand belongs with that arm.

I agree,Buckeyegal. When I was watching last night,my first guess was Amanda as she was approaching,then when he was kneeling.

[Lynn7]

Originally Posted by OutsideLookinIn

Matt's smile and facial expression to me points to Amanda... It's like I've seen him with that kind of facial expression with her before

Thanks Lynn for these SC!

Btw, what's the difference with all F3 elbows???

Well, Shayne has more of what I would call a 'teenage pudginess' to it still. Chelsea has a very pronounce bump of skin that protrudes from her elbow although it is kind of bony and her forearm is muscular with an indentation. Amanda's arms arm thin and she does have a dimple at the elbow like Shayne does. Chelsea doesn't have that. I think Chelsea is F3.

[Cornfritter]

Originally Posted by Lynn7

Well, Shayne has more of what I would call a 'teenage pudginess' to it still. Chelsea has a very pronounce bump of skin that protrudes from her elbow although it is kind of bony and her forearm is muscular with an indentation. Amanda's arms arm thin and she does have a dimple at the elbow like Shayne does. Chelsea doesn't have that. I think Chelsea is F3.

Hi Lynn, take a look post #150 Shanye's left elbow jmo the small dimple look the same as the chosen one. What do you think?