Hands, hands and more hands

[Mamai]

I knew it! It's Fake Mom!

[Google]

 

[beeleever]

Originally Posted by looselips

OK, maybe I'm dense... but just because we have a screencap of a thumb, why should we assume that it's the thumb of F1? I seem to recall many a bachelor taking the hand of the F2 just before he sent her packing. What's to stop TPTB from slipping that shot in the mix? If they had given us a shot of him putting the ring on the hand, I'd buy it. But a lone thumb? Not so much.

JMO, for what it's worth.

I think it is because the blue ring box is on the table behind the picture with the thumb.

[Mike'sgirl]

Originally Posted by looselips

OK, maybe I'm dense... but just because we have a screencap of a thumb, why should we assume that it's the thumb of F1? I seem to recall many a bachelor taking the hand of the F2 just before he sent her packing. What's to stop TPTB from slipping that shot in the mix? If they had given us a shot of him putting the ring on the hand, I'd buy it. But a lone thumb? Not so much.

JMO, for what it's worth.

The blue ring box shows up behind the hand - not likely that he left that sitting out while he gets rid of F2. The box is out and the ring in his hand to give to Shayne.

[Ryvetted]

Originally Posted by beeleever

I think it is because the blue ring box is on the table behind the picture with the thumb.

And it looks like he's sliding the ring on that hand too.

[Netcam]

If you think it's Shayne, then it's probably all done (the easy reveal) as part of this promotional deal, to sell Shayne the actress to Hollywood. Now she has 2-3 weeks of free publicity and rumors courtesy of TMZ, People, blogs, etc. And her mother did tell Matt that he would have to cope with Shayne becoming a big 'star' and doing red carpets, lol. Her father even said this show was her tv chance!

Otherwise, its a big red herring ... anyone have a SC of Chelsea's hand?? Don't forget she is can arm wrestle, her thumb can easily be short and wide!!

[bamabrain]

Originally Posted by KashatheDiva

No doubt that is Shayne's hand.
Now who goes Chelsea or Amanda?

Amanda's bye-bye. The edit of her fake family took all of the time. No time for her story to "arc" now. Chelsea's in the perfect spot with perfect family edit.

[looselips]

Originally Posted by Mike'sgirl

The blue ring box shows up behind the hand - not likely that he left that sitting out while he gets rid of F2. The box is out and the ring in his hand to give to Shayne.

OK, thanks. I missed the ring box.

Well, regardless, you could convince me that the thumb belongs to any of the F3. At first glance it does seem like Shayne's, but I just held my own hand up to it and it matches my own thumb very closely -- and I have long, thin fingers like Amanda. So who knows? I mean, it's a thumb! A thumb!!

Anyway, I'm just kind of laughing at the ridiculousness of it all, because after the scripted performances I saw by Shayne, Chelsea and Amanda (they are probably all swell people, but I honestly thought every situation they were in and everything they said was set up and/or scripted).... I honestly think that Matt would have a longer relationship with a finger puppet. I'd like to see one on that thumb.

[candimichele]

I knew it! It's Fake Mom!

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v364/sillygoosemama/hand.jpg

[Lynn7]

Does anyone have any good screencaps of Shayne's thumb? I looked through all of my photos and her thumb is hidden or she has her hands clasped.

[sanlee]

I posted some earlier...here they are ~ Not that they help much though.