I predicted this loooong ago, that he'd drop the WWJD bomb.
What an idiot!
You haven't even gotten to First Base yet and your putting forth your religious fervor?! WTF!
If he met her at a bar, would his opening line be the same thing? "Hi, My name is Michael and I believe in Jeeee-sus! How long can you be on your knees? Wanna come back to my place and pray?"
I'd toss a drink in the dorks face and say, "You've just been re-babtised! Praise the Lord!"