I think it will be interesting to see how the guys act when the tables are turned. They probably would think Melana was shallow if she didn't look at them next to a great-looking guy, but they might feel justified in thinking they are above dating a fat girl who has Melana's personality.
I agree with the comment above that this show would not work with a bunch of plain Janes trying to get the handsome guy. With Average Joe, everyone is thinking that the girl will be a shallow witch if she doesn't give the average guys a good chance for romance. If the show was called Average Jane, I think the comments would be more on the side of the good-looking guy, with people saying that it is disgusting that they expect him to date these girls or how could that fat girl dare to think she could ever date him? I could be wrong, but I just think society accepts heavier, plainer guys and the idea of them with a good-looking woman (especially if the guy has money) much easier than they would accept the reverse. A double standard which stinks, in my opinion.