Overated & underated !

[duckiies]

I loved Lisa but she did have some crappy shots. I really don't like her recycling or flowers shot (it was too strong and powerful for a simple bamboo theme), but other than that I like most of her photographs. Her personality reminds me of Kelly from The Biggest Loser. Always sad

[Wiest]

This is totally how I feel. I thought her recycling photos was one of the worst in the whole season, honestly. And she always seemed vacant, even out of photos.

Completely agree. Even when she was just sitting around the house or socializing with the other girls she always had that clenched jaw, directionless stare look going on as if she was severely perplexed by everything. I'm not saying she's unintelligent or anything though.

[ClrDeLun]

I didn't like what they did with her makeover (AJ-style, my hiney, it was a poodle!) and her gargoyle and smoking were ~electric~ and her performance in the music video was fantastic as was her CG Queen photo but I DETESTED her recycling shot! Her flower shot was so disappointing as well. I blame the recycling one, though, on Tyra because Jay said she had a fantastic shoot. Still, as slightly uneven as she was, I felt she had more to give when she left and felt is was a mistake.

I really didn't mind her general demeanor as that much of a problem but she looked like she had a lot riding on the competition. And add stress to the equation and I'm actually kinda surprised she wasn't crying at every turn.

[LedZepForever]

IMO, Shannon was extremely underrated. I know people have generally forgotten about her, but she had a great body and bone structure. She also got a fair amount of post-show work. I thought she had a lot more potential than a lot of the girls in Cycle 1 (besides Elyse).

[duckiies]

IMO, Shannon was extremely underrated. I know people have generally forgotten about her, but she had a great body and bone structure. She also got a fair amount of post-show work. I thought she had a lot more potential than a lot of the girls in Cycle 1 (besides Elyse).

I agree. I like Shannon, but I don't particularly think she deserved top three.

[LedZepForever]

I agree. I like Shannon, but I don't particularly think she deserved top three.

Who do you think deserved to make the top 3 instead? I didn't think the girls that cycle were that great (obviously excluding Elyse).

[duckiies]

Who do you think deserved to make the top 3 instead? I didn't think the girls that cycle were that great (obviously excluding Elyse).

Although Giselle was so annoying, I actually thought she had some great photos. But if not her than Shannon I guess. I don't know Maybe Shannon did deserve it. I need to watch more of cycle one.

[Afrocentric]

Katarzyna is extremely overrated. So is Whitney. Lauren too, kinda.

[LedZepForever]

Although Giselle was so annoying, I actually thought she had some great photos. But if not her than Shannon I guess. I don't know Maybe Shannon did deserve it. I need to watch more of cycle one.

So that's Shannon, Giselle, and Elyse? Isn't that 3 girls?

[hottfroggy77]

Katarzyna is extremely overrated. So is Whitney. Lauren too, kinda.

i agree with the comment in red! katarzyna gets so much praise and for what? her mediocre look and portfolio?


as for whitney, i actually would consider her underrated