Who should have won?

[ILuvRobin]

The reason why the judges spoke so highly of Shannon is because body of work means little compared to the end result. It took the body of work to get you there but whoever the winner is can be determined by what's there now, not who racked up the most points by winning the tests. Otherwise Elyse would not have been eliminated.

Well, I thought Adrienne and Elyse were neck and neck and that Shannon was close too..so to me I felt the most consistent would win and the most adaptible to would win...like I said it would not suprised if shannon won, because I felt she had that in her, but Adrienne was consistent and plus Tyra wanted a model they could mold

[Deep Dish]

...so to me I felt the most consistent would win and the most adaptible to would win...Adrienne was consistent and plus Tyra wanted a model they could mold

She wasn't adaptable on the Paris go sees and she wasn't adapatable to the NYC Fashion Week runway. She wasn't adaptable to commercials (ask the director) or in her interview. She didn't adapt to dainty Wonderbra lingerie either. Where is the adaptability? The molding?

[ILuvRobin]

you are right...that is why at first I would have not voted for her, but you could see the improvement, especially with the socialites...she stunned me, that is when I knew she could win, and I had to take her seriously

[Deep Dish]

Chatting up some French guys was the most irrelevant test of all. Every other thing I listed she was no more than 3rd or 4th best.

[ILuvRobin]

the only reason I say that, because it show that she fit in setting such as that...I think that was important

[Deep Dish]

They all fit. Eating in a restaurant, attending an event and having a conversation with other humans isn't difficult. It doesn't matter if it's in Paris or Newark. The only malcontent that doesn't know how to comport herself is Robin.

[stickwich]

So... out of all ten who started, who would you have picked to win?

Adrianne should have won... and did.

[mark]

shannon

[Cyaron]

Adrianne kicks major forms of ass, and it would have been like "NOOOOO!!!!" if anyone else would have won ... especially Shannon with that goofy mouth of hers.

Sorry to disagree with ya there, Mark.


Cyaron

http://groups.yahoo.com/group/adriannecurryrox/
Adrianne fans go to this url ^

[Deep Dish]

It was Beau that told Adrianne she had a "goofy smile."