Unfortunately, based on the pics, they pretty much HAD to eliminate Catherine. I'm sure it was tough, considering how much potential she has....certainly more, IMO, than Eboni. Plus, I refuse to believe that the picture Tyra chose was Catherine's best shot.
I think at least one of the UK girls agreed with Laura about Eboni being very vain.
I didn't think Sophie's picture was nearly as bad as the judges made it seem. Laura and Annaliese had the best pics this week, but Sophie wasn't bad either. I think the judges definitely give conflicting critiques. They tell the models that their job is to show off the garment, but then when they do that, they complain that the model isn't standing out.