There are THREE judges, not ONE judge, jury, and executioner. Each judge is ENTITLED to an opinion, which may or may not agree with yours. That doesn't mean they are WRONG. They just disagree with you.
And you are every bit as annoying and egocentric as I feared you would be when they hired you for the show. I tried to watch, but I'll be DVRing from now on so I can fast forward through you and your overbearing attitude.