I guess each to their own. I thought Pia was the best tonight with Casey right behind. I'd probably put Paul my 3rd favorite, not because his voice is better but I really enjoyed his performance.
Lauren & Jacob did very well and Scotty made me smile. James was just okay to me but I love George Harrison's version and hated the ending.
I really hated Haley's performance. Too screamy and not in a good (Janis) way. Stefano's sounding the same every week and is too loungy for me.
I think Stefano's at risk of going home and Haley may make the b3 this week. I would have thought Paul would be there too but think he helped himself. Jacob could be there because of the death spot but should be okay.
Everybody was really great tonight.
Loved Scotty tonight...not only was he a fun performer..his voice is fantastic too.
I think Jacob is in danger of leaving. Pia and Haley and Paul maybe too.
As a kid, she noticed she looked JUST like Steven's daughter Mia...whom he had with a different woman. Liv figured it out because of her resemblance to Mia and all parties came clean.
I've heard her say she loves having two great dads..Todd and Steven.
Ain't Love Grand!
I really liked James's verson of "While My Guitar... " Not quite as good as if Adam had done it, though. Adam probably would have omitted the scream at the end and sung it straight.
However, I meant to say earlier -- was anyone distracted by the way James was lit from behind, which made his ears glow red? It reminded me of that scene in Home Alone 2 where Kevin holds an electric candle behind his brother Buzz's ears during the Christmas choral concert.
But I closed my eyes and just listened, and truly enjoyed the song.
UGH. Paul just ruined that song for me forever. Go home now, please. Also, what's up with the glowing teeth? Creepy.
Scotty should do a Wade Hayes song, their voices are so similar. He has natural talent and whether he wins or loses this thing ... he's already won.
"Being famous does not make you a hero." Zeus in Hercules
I would have a really hard time picking a favorite tonight, though. All were various degrees of "good". No clunkers tonight at all. Very entertaining show!
Okay, Paul somehow did redeem himself tonight, for me. I was onboard a long time ago, but it's been rough ever since - then tonight I could see some of that appeal back again. It was a fun song.
I also liked Casey tonight, and Scotty ... a lot. I love Elvis. Pia's voice sounded very good, and I liked her better than I have before.
I am not a Jacob fan, and was surprised that some posters here think he'll be going home. I think with all the glowing reviews he gets, he'll be around a little longer. But if he does get booted, that will be okay with me. Or Stephano. Haley did okay, but she's my least favorite of the girls left.
The one I worry about for votes is James. His performance was good, just not the standout that we usually get, so he may be overlooked during the voting. Hopefully his fans will still be determined to vote a lot and keep him alive in this. I usually enjoy James a lot!