I completely agree with your assessment of the girls. I'm not quite ready to write off the guys, however. Michael and Casey are in a position to move in to Idol territory depending on how they play out the theme weeks. Remember, at this time last year Kris was practically invisible and Adam looked talented, but probably too specialized and weird for the Idol demographic. There is a lot of ground to cover before (to steal Michael Slezak's phrase) "the Mariah Carrey wannabe sings".Originally Posted by Krom;3852039;
But specifically as for Siobhan - I am definitely a fan. So far, she's my favorite.