I'll never understand why they put Josiah through to the top 50 after his bad performance only to cut him, but then put those people that you mentioned above in over him. He seemed to get a lot of post show support from fans, so best of luck to him. I hope he's very successful.i definitely think he deserved a spot in the top 24 especially over people like colton, garrett, luke, and jason yeager talk about yawnsville. its like who the hell were they and why out of thousands of people were they let in?
Completely agree.even though he didn't have the best voice at least he was interesting and had a great story (living in his car) which america would have eaten up. the producers probably thought if they let him in he would probably get far and maybe ruin their plans of getting their favorites eg david archuleta, carly the win.