I don't think any of them should have been kicked off. Sarah was NOT. Frenchie WAS. Trenyce was NOT. I think it was right to remove Jaered Andrews from the competition, who has been charged with manslaughter, apparently. And Frenchie's case is not so cut-and-dry- the website she posed topless for advertised itself as under-18 pics, so it's murky area.Originally posted by SnowflakeGirl
You make a good point here, Thonolan, and I agree with you wholeheartedly.
I don't think it's fair to condemn any of these women for the mistakes and/or choices they've made in their past if it has nothing to do with their performances on the show. We can evaluate them on their singing, or current behavior, as long as it's relevant to the show, but what right do we have to scour their pasts? I also find it distressing that people would vilify Frenchie (or even Sarah, of Joe Millionaire) for doing something that is completely legal, and I still don't think it was right to kick Frenchie off the show.
I hope this doesn't hurt Trenyce in the long-run, but it very well might.