Which of these already aspiring artists would win, or make it as a finalist on American Idol? Throw in opinions on who the judges would've loved, who has merely the look instead of the talent, which theme would fit which artist, or who would surely have been eliminated or stayed awhile throughout.
Among these stars, I think Justin Timberlake would win. He has that high crooner voice, an energetic performance vibe, and the sensational image.
Also add who I missed or who deserves to be included if you have one.