I thought that Josh did a great job with the song, I just wish that he would STOP milking the "I'm a marine, I have a little girl" thing... he doesn't NEED that, he has a good voice and shouldn't try to get by on a gimmic..... Anyway, I thought he did great tonight, it will be interesting to see if america will vote for a country singer to win the American Idol crown... one thing that I am curious about though, when he said he was going to be country from here on out.... how can you really do that with different themes each week? I guess you could try to find a country song for each theme, but I think that will be tough... I missed last weeks show (grrrrrr! damn miami making me be on the beach!) but I can't believe how good everyone is doing tonight... think it will go downhill now that we have heard Ruben, Trenyce, Clay, and Josh?