I thought her choice of outfit and song were both weak. She looked okay in her "gangster" look, but she's pretty--why hide hair? Also, whomever has been doing her makeup lately really loves that raccoon look. No need to use a Marks-a-lot for eye liner, in my view.
The song--she did fine with it overall. I agree with the yelling comment on the high ones. She does that--I think it's odd. She's a good singer; there's no need to over-extend. Regarding the choice, I wonder how the singers/competitors were restricted/guided in their choices. I guess that the song had to be a cover that would be recognized internationally, but why a Carole King song that really has been sung to death. Again, I say that Kelly did fine with it, but why not pick something more interesting or beautiful?