You really think they should have only one boy, superfly?
For a group singing, I think there should be a mix, and only having one boy could make it difficult.
Also, the target audience for the group will be teenage girls, they'll be the ones to make it successful, so if I was the manager or a producer, I would want more than just one boy in it.
By the way, I watched Tuesday's show again, and I'm really starting to think the judges were way too harsh on Brennan, I think he did well. But because of the judges comments and the general reaction on the board, and Canyon's popularity, I don't think Brennan will make it.
Anyone know if Brennan or Canyon attend a school for the arts like A.J. does? I would guess not. I think you can really see the difference that makes.