[QUOTE=Tigerusty;3889412;]It's not a knee-jerk reaction becuase those that are defending her still believe she's one of the best voices idol has ever had and I once again can't disagree anymore than I do with the rest of what you wrote. She has a beautifully trained instrument and if she's a one trick pony I'm Crystal Bowersox. I have now come to the belief that Barbra Streisand and Judy Garland would have been voted out early on this show with people posting the same things about them.[/QUOTE]

It's as if we were separated at birth!! I couldn't agree with you more!!!