Who Will Be the New Judges in Season 12?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by razorbacker

Fox made it official today. Nikki Minaj & Keith Urban join the judges panel.

---

Keith Urban is dreamy! Hope he does well in this format. Wonder how many new singles he will debut on the show? At least they will be more family friendly than JLo's or Nicki Minaj's.

I'm overloaded with singing competitions so I don't know if I will tune in.




Heck what am I saying? If Keith Urban is there I will have to watch. Or at least when he is talking. :biglove

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by JunkieGirl

Keith Urban is dreamy! Hope he does well in this format. Wonder how many new singles he will debut on the show? At least they will be more family friendly than JLo's or Nicki Minaj's.

I'm overloaded with singing competitions so I don't know if I will tune in.




Heck what am I saying? If Keith Urban is there I will have to watch. Or at least when he is talking. :biglove

---

I keep reading that comment a lot. Keith seems to be winning over some folks who swore to not watch if Nikki Minaj were involved. Certainly, as always, I'll be tuned in but I'll reserve comments until I see them in action.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by JohnnyK

As long as we start having more diverse and better winners, I don't care who the judges are.

---

Right? If not, then I guess I'll be able to pick the winner again once it gets down to the 24 or so. But as I see it now, teenage girls make up the majority of voters/watchers, so there probably won't be a change.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by JohnnyK

Right? If not, then I guess I'll be able to pick the winner again once it gets down to the 24 or so. But as I see it now, teenage girls make up the majority of voters/watchers, so there probably won't be a change.

---

Yep, if the show doesn't make changes regarding the voting the same type of winner will win year after year. Keep doing what they are doing and they will never find a Kelly, Carrie or JHud.

The demographic who watches this show is getting older and older. But are they spending 2 hours sending a thousand texts? Probably not. They are probably still voting but not to the extent that the teens are.

It's us teens that stay up all night. At first I blamed the cougars but now I blame them. Or maybe a mix of the two, I don't know.

I want a female winner. We haven't had one since Jordin.

I have no feelings one way or another for Keith. But Nicki? I'm out. At least I'll have more free time from January thru May (to watch some non-reality shows that I'm liking more than reality shows!).

Steven Tyler is letting it be known that he would like back in on Idol as a mentor, not as a judge.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by razorbacker

Steven Tyler is letting it be known that he would like back in on Idol as a mentor, not as a judge.

---

Oh yea...he always had so much to offer

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ibot2much

Oh yea...he always had so much to offer

---

I was thinking the very same thing. He always looked bored, and a bit pervy

As much as I think Keith Urban is pretty good and nice to look at, the other two do not make me want to watch.