5/16 AI 11 Performance: Final Three **West Coast Spoilers**

[Eastcoastmom]

Randy, what are you smoking? Come on, that Seger performance was adequate, if that. Of course, jmho.

[waywyrd]

Yikes. That song showcased all the weaknesses in Phillip's voice.

So of course the judges give it a standing O.

[TeacherLady]

I would have thought that would be a good song for Phillip, but I think it exposed his shortcomings as a singer. Aw, shut up, Randy!

Steven: "It doesn't matter if you hit the notes or not." What?!?

[ilja]

Okay, who here is a lip reader?

[AsIs]

OMG, Tyler just said "It doesn't matter if you hit the notes or not!!!"

This show is officially off the rails. All your Idol has to do now is occasionally sing the melody. They don't even have to hit the notes. Wow, the bar has dropped.

I like some stuff Phillip does. But Joshua or Jessica can grow into a Idol. They aren't there yet, but they can grow into it. Phillip doesn't have the range to do it. He can have nice career, but he won't fill stadiums.

[WalaLang]

Rooting for a P2 and Jessica for final 2. And I would be happy if either wins.

[TeacherLady]

For me, Joshua needs to win, with Jessica 2nd and Phillip 3rd. But I'm afraid that won't happen...

[BTW]

Having a hard time getting any lines open for Phillip. Jessica easy to get to. Am not even trying Joshua. I can't take all his screaming. I loved Phillip's last song. Kind of hoping for a Jessica win though.

[Jexter]

This has been a very boring season (but I miss Simon and Paula). IMO, the boys should go to the end. Jessica as no charisma but a beautiful voice. Phillip has tremendous charisma and a unique voice. I'd take that combo any day over someone who is just boring to watch.

Joshua should win. He has it all. Plus, I'd like to see an African American male win this thing before the show goes under.

[Eastcoastmom]

Okay, so I just realized that the song P2 sang was Beggin. I thought he was singing "Megan" The judges said by Madcon, whom I don't know but it is originally a Frankie Valli and the Four Seasons song. Ha! Went over to listen to the Madcon version and that was pretty cool, too.

Frankie Valli & The Four Seasons - Beggin - Original - YouTube