5/9 AI 11 Performance Show: Top Four **West Coast Spoilers**

[WinkyD]

Holly was dull, IMO.

[ilja]

And here I was thinking Phillip finally found a song with notes he could hit.

[murphytoo]

Holly has become my favorite - but that song didn't showcase her voice well enough.

[navybelle]

I really like Phillip's voice and enjoy listening/watching him. Hollie's doing a good job with the Journey song - I was concerned at first, but I like how she sounds doing it. It's just not the type of song I pictured her picking.

[murphytoo]

I would've easily won my bet that Randy would name drop Journey - but no one here would take it.

[ilja]

Holly was dull, IMO.

I thought she sounded wonderful but do wish she would show more emotion. I wonder if it's just that she hasn't had that much life experience yet.

[Gutmutter]

Just ran in the door - doesn't sound like I missed much with PP, but loved Hollie. She's sounding really good.

[xmaskat]

The judges were more impressed with Hollie's performance than I was. I felt emotion was lacking from the song.

[murphytoo]

Hubby says "so far tonight, Steven is coherent".

[ranger1rg]

I must be hearing things, because I thought Phillip sounded ill and Holliw sounded terrible. Neither one sang like an Idol.

Hollie's been so good the past few weeks, but that performance has to hurt her. Nothing seems to hurt Phillip.