5/12 Elimination Show Discussion *Spoilers*

[Doats]

I am upset to the max.

Will read here for the rest of the season but no way do I think James should have left before Haley and Lauren.

[AsIs]

I'm not a fan of Jame's singing. That is nothing against him as a person. What he has done this season has been AWESOME and he should be very proud of himself. Even falling short of the finale opens so many doors. If he is good, he will have a career now.

And Haley lovers? What about the Scotty and Lauren lovers...?

[JenCos]

I would so rather have James than Lauren! But I am thrilled that Haley did not get eliminated

[ranger1rg]

james has a great story.

what a lousy shame that he's going home.

[Doats]

On the upside--just like Daughtry...

[bee stung lips]

My son will be heart-broken.

The upside is that he will do well beyond this show....I really feel he will. He certainly deserves that chance.

[VoiceOfReason]

Wow, I'm shocked. The #4 curse lives, James joins a great group of contestants ousted at that spot headlined by Tamyra, Letoya, & Chris Daughtry.

[mnmhughes]

You know, it's funny. If the judges hadn't been so vicious to Haley last night, her fan base wouldn't have been mobilized and James probably would have stayed. So the judges have no one to blame but themselves!!

[fan*addict]

aawwwww although I am not a HUGE James fan..I thought he deserved to stay over Scotty....someone needs to get Scotty OFF MY TV!

[Gina28]

Saddest night ever on this show for me. I'm done. My heart is broken. Good luck to the F3 ~ I won't watch. I'm done ever watching this show. The Voice is a better show anyway. All the teenyboppers voted a gazillion times and got all the 16 yr. old teens in the finale. I hope they do as well in school as they vote online.

GodSpeed James Durbin..you will be missed and good luck!!!