5/11 Show Discussion *Spoilers*

[WinkyD]

Playin' to the base; jes' playin' to the base. Y'all. ;-)

[Quemoni]

Hayley did her thang the second time around.

Scotty I love his baritone voice BUT he has no range and no versatility. Well, he has never shown it. I almost miss the Idols when each week was a different genre. Can he do something outside of country & blues? Probably not.

James? Pop? Hip Hop? Jazz? Maybe.

Lauren? Big Band? Rap? Opera? Possibly.

Hayley? ABSOLUTELY! I think she has the talent to do any genre.

[Lil Bit]

GaGa is a good role model for teen girls?!?!?! Now I've heard it all.

[WinkyD]

Lady Gaga is a self-made phee-nom; that is a good role-model for anyone.

But whom is Lauren trying to kid? When she began this "journey," she was a flirt. Now she has no clue? Please.

[navybelle]

This song isn't doing Scotty any favors.

He looked so creepy singing it! Back to the weird faces again - I almost forgot about them....
The song was just okay, but his performance was strange.

[Babbred]

Not really impressed with Lauren. Didn't feel any emotional connection to the song.

[Magnum]

I agree with Steven- Haleys first song was great

[Quemoni]

Lauren lost it towards the end of the song.

Ok. If she didn't want to call herself EVIL then why did she select that song?

LOL at Gaga convincing Lauren to go ahead...be evil. Do it! Do it!

And that is what happens to kiddos in the industry. Why not just pick another song and stand your ground?

[waywyrd]

Scotty and Lauren bored me in round 1.

They bored me in both rounds.

How does James get to go first AND last? Sheesh.

[mnmhughes]

Does anyone else think that the audience seemed kind of lukewarm towards Lauren tonight? I wonder if she's going to make it into the F3.