5/11 Show Discussion *Spoilers*

[waywyrd]

I'm confused. They thought James was awesome/beautiful/insert tired-ass description here, but they trash Haley, who sounded miles better?

At least Steven heard what I did.

[Quemoni]

I was not impressed by James. Hayley is my pick of who should win. They alwayssss give her a hard time. She has the best vocal ability out of every one left. She has range and they keep trying to pigeon hole her.

[Babbred]

They weren't being hateful, they were being honest. It was terrible. You're right, PR, it made my throat hurt, too.

[mnmhughes]

I don't mind the judges criticizing Haley, but for several weeks now, she has been the ONLY one they have criticized. Pass it around a little is all I'm asking!

[newshound]

I liked Haley's performance and song choice, but I agree that her back talk to the judges will not help her. It's just not cool to argue with the judges' constructive criticism.

[Crushed]

How the hell do they think James is so amazing? I'm confused. He's not terrible. But vocally, is he that great?

[Babbred]

I thought they should have nailed James, too. I was totally unimpressed by him. Just karaoke.

[Babycakee]

They're going to continue to "pimp" James, Lauren and Scottie. Poor Haley, they seem to really have it out for her. I like James but Haley knocked it out of the park compared to James tonight.

[bee stung lips]

I'm confused. They thought James was awesome/beautiful/insert tired-ass description here, but they trash Haley, who sounded miles better?

At least Steven heard what I did.

I heard what you heard too.

[Babbred]

I've turned the volume down. Not interested in hearing Haley say how right she is. You'd better step it up with the other song, girl, or you're in trouble tomorrow.