4/27 Show Discussion *Spoilers*

[Gutmutter]

Lauren/Scotty interview--- awkward! but the duet is sounding good.

[mom3]

I was thinking that and remembering "In a Dream" and just how effective that was.

Exactly what I was thinking about. That was probably my favorite Idol moment ever.

[fijibeachbum]

Scotty and Lauren sing "Up on the Roof."

Ryan tries to make more of their relationship than brother and sister. Scotty's not letting him.

It sounds pretty good. A few odd notes, but overall, not bad. These two should both sing with each other on the other's albums.

[prhoshay]

Loved Scotty's and Lauren's duet. Country twist on a doo-wop song.

[libgirl2]

Exactly what I was thinking about. That was probably my favorite Idol moment ever.

Mine too!

[Doats]

Wasn't crazy about Lauren and Scotty's duet. Their harmonies sounded strained to me tonight, not like in their past duets.

[I'm MEL]

Love Lauren's boots. Love this song!

They sound great! Lauren seems very comfortable with this style and shines - Scotty is good with her.

[fijibeachbum]

Wasn't crazy about Lauren and Scotty's duet. Their harmonies sounded strained to me tonight, not like in their past duets.

I agree. It didn't mesh well. Maybe that's what Jennifer was inferring when she mentioned how hard it is to sing behind a big voice (talking to Scotty).

[bee stung lips]

I wish that James had sung the entire song like the beginning, without going into the 'rock' vibe. The beginning of the song was just perfect.

Same here. I loved the tenderness of his voice in the beginning. It would have been nice had he kept that up. His performance was great just the same.

[bee stung lips]

I love Casey in this element.