4/13 Show Discussion *Spoilers*

[Gutmutter]

I will be really surprised if he goes tomorrow. They really propped him up tonight. Maybe that was their apology.

[Jasmine305]

Of the three I've seen so far Stefano has been the best and Paul should be going home IMO.

[prhoshay]

When Stefano was speaking, between commercials, I had to turn and look at the television because I thought it was a woman speaking!!

[Babbred]

Of the three I've seen so far Stefano has been the best...

Sorry, but I love Paul so wouldn't mind him sticking around.

[mnmhughes]

Poor Stefano. The judges owe him an apology.

He has a really good voice and he's really working at improving. He needs a stylist tonight.

His dad looks really proud.

I thought he did a good job. I hate to even listen to the judges at this point. They don't have anything to add.

I think it would be more interesting to see a live scroll on the Idol stage monitors displaying what America thinks of the performers. More interesting -- and more honest.

[waywyrd]

Wow, Scotty sings country tonight. Shocking!

[Unklescott]

Scotty to perform George Strait's Cross My Heart.

[ranger1rg]

does anybody else hate the way scotty holds the mic and tilts his head? and then makes those god-awful faces?

[Gutmutter]

Rats! I would have liked to hear "Everybody's Talkin' 'Bout Me". This is just same old, same old.

[ranger1rg]

scotty sounds flat to me, and i don't like this song, either.

his worst performance.