4/6 Show Discussion *Spoilers*

[GT Mom]

Still like Jacob - I thought that was great!

[mom3]

Haley taking on Janis Joplin... ought to be interesting.

[bee stung lips]

Haley taking on Janis...as in Janis Joplin...uh-oh...this is certain to be a growl-fest.

[WinkyD]

Ryan thought Jacob's "hip thrust was impressive"?

[Quemoni]

Sigh. I can't stomach seeing Jacob perform and I despise that vibrato thing he does when he sings. Ilk. He sounded much better towards the end. OH, was he wearing clear lip gloss?

[Gutmutter]

Tonight is the first time I've ever enjoyed Jacob's singing. I applaud his choice to sing a song that he's comfortable with idealogically. Cool reveal that his back-up singer wrote the song!

[maude~flanders]

I predict Jacob in the B3 tomorrow, America doesn't like their contestants arrogant. "If I'm in the bottom 3 it's not because I sang the song right but it's because America isn't ready to look in the mirror." And then he proceeds to sing the song horribly with some gawd awful gyrations. He really should have stuck with his first choice. I thought this was bad and I usually like Jacob, no wonder he was first.

I like that he changed the song because he didn't feel comfortable with it, but I agree with your comments that his remarks could hurt him in the voting.

[Harmony2000]

I think I'm over Jacob, that was dreadful. Will this judges ever give an honest critique beyond "that was beautiful, that was hot" again?

Next we have growl...mumble...growl...Haley taking on Janis J. Should be awesome (but only not).

[waywyrd]

Sigh. I can't stomach seeing Jacob perform and I despise that vibrato thing he does when he sings.

So glad I'm not the only one. I've never been impressed with him.

Here's hoping Haley does Janis some justice. She has the voice for it, if she leaves out the silly growling.

[xmaskat]

I'm not a Jacob fan but I thought he was better tonight than most weeks. He kept the caterwalling to a minimum for a change.