Season 10 Prediction Game

[jsciv]

It seems to be touch & go right now as to whether or not Casey is going to be able to continue. He has had a transfusion & the men's performances are filmed tonight. They may let him out to p-erform & then send him back to the hospital. Can I change my predictions if he doesn't make it?

One of the reasons to wait until the performances are done to cast your votes!

Let's see what happens.

[r2maybs]

How is this going to happen this week? We just choose the 5 for each sex and 3 wild cards?

[Little Sew&Sew]

My "predictions". My "wish list" is much different!

Guys

Paul
Jovany
Casey
James
Brett
Robbie (WC)

Girls

Pia
Thia
Lauren A.
Lauren T.
Haley
Karen (WC)

[jacobson00]

Lauren Alaina
Haley Reinhart
THia
Naima
Karen Rodriguez
Pia Toscano

Guys
Casey Abrams
Jacob Lusk
Paul McDonald
James Durbin
Robbie Rosen
Scotty McCreary

[RyMac]

I'll play. For some reason though, I'm thinking each judge will get a wildcard pick, and we'll end up with a top 13. I don't know why I think that. Maybe I dreamed it?

Top 5 Guys:

Casey Abrams
Jacob Lusk
James Durbin (unfortunately)
Scotty McCreery
Paul MacDonald

Top 5 Girls:
Pia Toscano
Lauren Alaina
Ashthon Jones
Karen Rodriguez
Thia Meguia (unfortunately)

Wild Cards:

Randy: Kendra Chantelle
Jennifer: Stefano
Steven: Julie Zorilla

[Ellen]

Boys
Scotty McCreery
Jacob Lusk
James Durbin
Stefano Langone
Paul McDonald
Casey Abrams (wild card)

Girls
Tatynisa Wilson
Julie Zorrilla
Lauren Alaina
Pia Toscano
Thia Megia
Kendra Chantelle (wild card)

There's a question as to whether there will be a third wild card. If there is, here's my third wild-card guess: Karen Rodriguez

[BuckeyeAddict]

I originally came up with 7 guys, and had to figure out who I didn't think would make it. For the girls, I only came up with 4 and had to figure out which 2 to add.

Like Little Sew&Sew, this isn't necessarily who I want, but who I think will make it. In first name order:

Girls:
Ashton (WC)
Haley
Karen
Lauren A.
Pia
Thia

Guys:
Casey
Jacob
James
Paul
Scotty
Tim (WC)

If all three judges do get a WC, then I'll go with....Lauren T. It should be a guy, based on talent, but if they want to make it 13, then they might want to give the girls an extra advantage. Although that might actually hurt them more than help them. Votes for girls (for those voting that way) would be more spread out.

[TNKY]

Am I too late to play? I had trouble getting on to this site until now. If I'm late, then just disregard this entry. I'm not sure if it's a top 12 or 13 so I am posting a top 13. If it is only a top 12, then please remove Ashton Jones as a wildcard pick.

Boys:

Jacob Lusk
James Durbin
Paul McDonald
Scotty McCreery
Casey Abrams
Stefano Lagone (Wildcard)
Jovany Barreto (Wildcard)

Girls

Lauren Alaina
Pia Toscano
Thia Megia
Karen Rodriguez
Naima Adedapo
Ashton Jones (Wildcard)---only if there is 13 contestants this season.

[r2maybs]

My choices:

Boys:
Scotty M
Jacob L
James D
Casey A
Stefano L
Wild Card: Paul M

Girls:
Thia M
Julie Z
Lauren A
Pia T
Tatynisa W
Wild Card: Karen R

3rd Wild card if there is one: Naima A

[Tigerusty]

I read that they aren't picking the wild cards until next Thursday after the remaining 14 perform again next Wednesday in a wild card round so I'm going to just pick the top 5 Girls and Guys.

Guys

James
Jacob
Casey
Scotty
Paul
Stefano (W)

Girls

Lauren A
Thia
Pia
Karen
Ashton
Julie (W)

Surprise 13th Naima

Now there is discussion that they are going back to their original plans of announcing the Wild Cards tonight so I'll include them in my picks(it looks like they are making their decisions on the fly)