4/27 Show Discussion *Spoilers*

[RealityLovesMe]

Wow. Lee is really horrible tonight. I'm watching online. Maybe it is just my speakers? My speakers tend to make the kids sound off but this was disturbingly bad.

[Krom]

Here's Shania's "Greatest Hits" album.

Whether or not they were all "legit" crossover hits is up to you to decide... in theory 21 songs.

Amazon.com: Shania Twain - Greatest Hits: Shania Twain: Music

listen 1. Forever And For Always 4:03 $0.99 Buy Track
listen 2. I'm Gonna Getcha Good! 4:02 $0.99 Buy Track
listen 3. Up! 2:53 $0.99 Buy Track
listen 4. Come On Over 2:54 $0.99 Buy Track
listen 5. Man! I Feel Like A Woman! 3:54 $0.99 Buy Track
listen 6. That Don't Impress Me Much 4:27 $0.99 Buy Track
listen 7. From This Moment On 3:55 $0.99 Buy Track
listen 8. Honey, I'm Home 3:37 $0.99 Buy Track
listen 9. You're Still The One 3:15 $0.99 Buy Track
listen 10. Don't Be Stupid (You Know I Love You) 3:35 $0.99 Buy Track
listen 11. Love Gets Me Every Time 3:33 $0.99 Buy Track
listen 12. No One Needs To Know 3:03 $0.99 Buy Track
listen 13. You Win My Love 3:45 $0.99 Buy Track
listen 14. (If You're Not In It For Love) I'm Outta Here! 3:48 $0.99 Buy Track
listen 15. The Woman In Me (Needs The Man In You) 3:57 $0.99 Buy Track
listen 16. Any Man Of Mine 4:07 $0.99 Buy Track
listen 17. Whose Bed Have Your Boots Been Under? 3:59 $0.99 Buy Track
listen 18. Party For Two (Pop Version With Intro) 3:31 $0.99 Buy Track
listen 19. Don't! 3:56 $0.99 Buy Track
listen 20. Party For Two (Country Version With Intro) 3:31 $0.99 Buy Track
listen 21. I Ain't No Quitter 3:30 $0.99 Buy Track

My own take? I personally "know" seven of them. And I admit I'm actually surprised its that many.

[mom3]

I didn't love that by Lee... it's a beautiful song, but it didn't come across that way to me. Obviously the judges heard something else.

[quentcomps]

I count three.

[ranger1rg]

shania twain was a GREAT guest judge, and more than deserving of the mentor slot.

she's sold a ton of cds, and i have NO problem with her catalog. we'll hear good country songs, and we won't get stuff we've heard multiple times before.

shania gave lee great advice, and it worked out for him. i thought he was really good.

[Babycakee]

MMmm Hmmm!! I have to admit I was worried about Lee singing this song but.... Loved his version And I'm a huge fan of this song.

[xmaskat]

Lee just gets better and better each week .

[TopCatDC]

Regarding Shania's catalog - one big advantage of doing Shania Night instead of generic Country Night is you are guaranteed a modern catalog (by Idol standards). Nothing is more than 15 years old.

[KofferMum]

I have a feeling that Lee's performance may be one of the best of the night, and that's not saying too too much. He sounded like he was straining through most of that key.

Shania is a true success story, she's been quite noble throughout her life. She deserves any and all success, but is she really current? I know she's divorced now and trying to make a 'come back', but not a sizable catalog and unless she can redo her radio takeover of the past, she's likely not to be pertintent again musically.

[RealityLovesMe]

I can't believe the judges liked that. Really? Oh well.
Since Mike is performing second, I'm guessing he will go home this week. Second is not a lucky spot. And I have a feeling the judges aren't going to be polite to him.